Man and the World of Stars
GA 219
16 December 1922, Dornach
V. Human Faculties and Their Connections with Elemental Beings
The faculties needed by man in order that he may be able to confront the world and work in it during earthly life are connected, as I have shown, with his activities in the spiritual world between death and rebirth. This means, however, that here on Earth man lives in certain spheres which on the Earth itself have no inherent reality, which manifest their reality only when observed in the supersensible realm.
We will turn our attention today to the three domains which actually comprise all human activity on Earth: to the thoughts through which man endeavors to assimilate Truth in the world; to feelings, in so far as in and through his world of feeling, man endeavors to assimilate the Beautiful; to his will-nature, in so far as he is meant to bring the Good to fulfilment through it.
When we speak of thoughts, we mean that domain through which Truth can be assimilated. But thoughts in themselves cannot be real. Precisely when we are clear that through our thoughts we have to inform ourselves about the truth of what is real, then it must also be admitted that thoughts, as such, cannot be anything real. Just imagine for a moment that you were to be fixed as firmly in your thoughts as you are in your brain or your heart; if that were the case, these thoughts would indeed be something real in themselves. We should not be able to assimilate reality through them. Nor could we ever express through human speech what human speech is intended to express if it contained full reality in the ordinary earthly sense. If every time we uttered a sentence we were obliged to work something heavy out of the mouth, we should be unable to express anything; it would rather be a matter of producing something. In this sense, what is spoken is not a reality in itself, but ‘signifies’ a reality, just as thoughts are not themselves a reality but merely signify a reality. And if we consider the Good, then we shall find that what is formed through physical reality can never be called the Good. We must bring up from the depths of our being the impulse to Goodness, at first as something entirely unreal, and then make it a reality. If the impulse to Goodness were to arise like hunger, as an external reality, Goodness is just what it could not be. Again, when you are looking at a statue it does not occur to you to think that you can converse with it. It is merely semblance; and in the semblance something is made manifest, namely: Beauty. So that in Truth, reality is certainly indicated; but Truth itself moves in an element of unreality; and it is the same with Beauty, the same with Goodness.
It is therefore necessary for man that his thoughts are not, in themselves, real. Just imagine—if thoughts were to wander around in the head like leaden figures, then, to be sure, you would be aware of a reality, but these leaden thoughts would not be able to signify anything to you, they would be something real themselves. As truly as Thoughts, as the Beautiful and the Good too cannot be directly real, so it is also true that reality is necessary in this physical-earthly world in order that we can have Thoughts, make the Beautiful manifest in the world through art, and also bring the Good to fulfilment.
In speaking of this I come today to a domain of Spiritual Science which can lead us very deeply into the spirituality that is around us here on Earth and is essential for earthly existence, but completely withdrawn from the observation possible to the senses and hence cannot be grasped by the ordinary consciousness which depends, as you know, entirely upon physical perception. The fact is that we are surrounded everywhere by spiritual beings of the greatest possible variety, only the ordinary consciousness does not perceive them. Their existence is necessary in order that as human beings we may be able to unfold our faculties, to have thoughts in their chimerical lightness and evanescence, so that they are not present in our heads like leaden weights, are not something real in themselves, but can ‘signify’ reality.
For this it is necessary that there should be beings in the world who prevent our thoughts with their non-reality from immediately vanishing from us again. We men are really too cumbersome, too ponderous, to be able without more ado to hold fast our thoughts with the ordinary consciousness. Elemental beings must be there, beings who help us ever and again to hold fast our thoughts. Such elemental beings are indeed present, only they are extraordinarily hard to discover because they always conceal themselves. When we ask: How does it really come about that we can hold fast a thought when it has no reality at all? Who is helping us to do this?—even then it is very easy to be deceived, precisely when the matter is considered in the light of Spiritual Science. For at the very moment we begin to ask ourselves the question: by whom are thoughts held fast for men?—through this very desire to know about the spirit-entities who hold thoughts fast, we are driven into the realm of the Ahrimanic beings; we plunge into the realm of these beings and very soon begin to believe—although it is of course a deceptive belief—that man must be supported by the Ahrimanic spirits in order to hold fast the thoughts, so that they shall not vanish the moment he grasps them. On this account, most people are—unconsciously—even grateful to the Ahrimanic beings for supporting them in their thinking. But it is misplaced gratitude, for there is a whole kingdom of beings who support us in our thought-world particularly, and who are by no means Ahrimanic.
These beings are difficult to find in the spiritual world, even for well-trained vision. One finds them sometimes by observing a very clever man at work; if one watches such a man one can perceive that he actually has a volatile, fleeting band of followers. He does not go about alone but has a fugitive following of spiritual beings who do not belong to the Ahrimanic kingdom, but who have an altogether remarkable character. One first really learns to know these beings when one can observe those other beings who belong to the Ahrimanic realm, to the elemental kingdoms, and therefore are not perceptible to the eyes of the senses, who are at work when forms in Nature, crystal forms, for example, arise. The activity of these beings underlies all form; you find them described in my Mystery Plays as beings who chisel and hammer out solid forms. If you think of the gnome-like beings in one of the Mystery PlaysNoteNumThe Soul's Awakening. Scene 2. you have there the beings who produce forms. Now these beings are sly and crafty—as you can see from the way I have presented them in the Play—and they mock at the scanty intelligence possessed by men. Call to mind those scenes from the Mystery Play if they are known to you.
Now if we observe a really clever man and perceive how he may have a retinue consisting of a whole host of such beings as I have described, we find that these beings are despised by the gnome-spirits of the elemental world because they are clumsy and, above all, because they are terribly foolish. Foolishness is their main characteristic! And so it can be said that precisely the very cleverest people in the world, when we can observe them from this aspect, are followed by whole troops of ‘spirit-fools.’ It is as if these foolish spirits wanted to belong to someone. And they are greatly disdained by the beings who fashion and shape forms in Nature in the way described in the Mystery Plays. We can therefore say: among the worlds unknown to begin with to ordinary consciousness, there is one that is peopled by a spirit-folk of ‘fools,’ fools who throng towards human wisdom and cleverness. In the present age these beings have actually no life of their own. They achieve a life by using the life of those who are dying, who are dying from illness but in whom life-forces are still present. These beings can only make use of a life that is past. Thus there are spirit-fools who use the life that remains over from men; they sate themselves with the life that lingers in cemeteries and such places.
It is when we penetrate into worlds like this that we realize how densely populated is the realm lying behind the world that is perceptible to the senses, how manifold are the classes of spirit-beings, and how closely connected these spirit-beings are with our faculties. A clever man pursuing his activities, who is merely clever and not clairvoyant, can hold fast his thoughts precisely through the fact that he is followed by this troop of spirit-fools. These spirit-fools rivet themselves to his thoughts, drag at them and give them weight, so that they remain with him, whereas otherwise they would quickly vanish from him.
These beings are, as I said, bitterly scoffed at by the gnome-like beings. The gnome-like beings will not tolerate them in their realm although they belong to it. The gnome-like beings drive the others away continually and there is a hard fight between the gnome-folk and this folk of spirit-fools through whom alone wisdom is made possible for man; otherwise the wisdom would be fugitive, would pass away the moment it came into existence, could not remain. As has been said, these beings are hard to discover because it is so easy to fall into the Ahrimanic sphere directly questions are asked about them. But one can find them on occasions such as I have just indicated, by observing very clever men who are followed by a whole troop of such beings. Apart from that, however, when there are not enough clever thoughts fastening on to men, these beings are to be found lingering, for example, in libraries—when the books contain clever material. When the contents of books are stupid these beings are not to be found; they are to be found only where there is cleverness. On that they rivet themselves.
This gives us some insight into a realm that surrounds us everywhere, that is present just as the Nature-kingdoms are present, that has something to do with our faculties, but is very difficult to assess. If we wish to do that we must rely upon those gnome-like beings and set some store by their judgment—and they, in fact, consider the other beings stupid and impudent.
But these other beings have yet another characteristic. When they are too severely persecuted by the gnome-like beings they escape into human heads, and whereas outside in Nature they are almost giants—of an enormous size—they become quite tiny when they are inside men's heads. One could say that they are an abnormal species of Nature-spirits, who are, however, intimately connected with the whole of human evolution on the Earth.
Beings of another kind live chiefly in the watery and airy elements, just as do those beings described in the Mystery Plays as the sylph-like beings. The beings to whom I am now referring have chiefly to do with the world of ‘beautiful semblance.’ They attach themselves less to men who are clever in the ordinary sense than to those who are genuinely artistic in nature. But these beings too are very hard to discover as they can so easily conceal themselves. They are to be found where there are genuine works of art, where, for instance, the human form or forms of Nature and so forth are portrayed in semblance. There they are to be found.
These beings too, as I said, can only be discovered with difficulty. When, for instance, we ask: How is it that beautiful semblance interests us, that there are occasions when we derive greater pleasure from a beautiful statue than from a living person (true, it is a different kind of pleasure, but for all that, greater), or that we are edified and delighted by melodies or harmonies? When we ask ourselves this we very easily fall into a different realm, into the realm of the Luciferic beings. It is not only the Luciferic beings who promote enthusiasm for art, but again there is a kingdom of elemental beings by whom interest in art is stimulated and kept alive in man. Without such beings, man would never be disposed to take an interest in beautiful semblance, simply because it is unreal.
Now the reason why it is so difficult to discover these beings is because they can conceal themselves even more easily than the spirit-fools, for they are actually only present where beauty makes its power felt. And when we are wrapt in enjoyment of the beautiful, then we certainly do not see these beings. Why is this?
In order to get a sight of them in a normal way, we must endeavor, while given up in some way to artistic impressions, to direct clairvoyant vision to the beings who are depicted in the same scene in the Mystery Play as nymph- or sylph-like beings; these beings too belong to the elemental Nature-kingdoms, and we must project ourselves into them. We must, as it were, look with these air- and water-beings at the others who are present whenever joy is taken in beauty. And as this is difficult, we must turn to other means of help. Now fortunately it is easy to discover these beings when we are listening to someone who speaks beautifully and whose language we do not properly understand; when we hear only the sounds without understanding the meaning. If we then abandon ourselves to the experience of this beautiful speaking—but it must be really beautiful speaking, genuine oratory, and we must not be able to understand it properly—then we can acquire the faculty, intimate and delicate as it is, of seeing these beings.
Thus we must try, as it were, to acquire the talent of the sylphs and to strengthen it through the talent that unfolds when we listen to beautiful speech without endeavoring to understand the meaning but having ears only for its beauty. Then we discover the beings who are present wherever beauty is and lend their support so that man can have a true interest in it.
And then follows the disillusionment, the great and terrible surprise. For these beings are in fact hideously ugly, the very ugliest that can be imagined; they are ghastly creatures, the very archetypes of ugliness. And if we have developed the requisite spiritual vision and visit some studio where artistic work is being done, we find that it is these beings who are present on Earth, like spiders on the ground of world-existence, in order that men may take interest in beauty. It is through these frightful spider-creatures of an elemental order that interest in beauty really awakens. Man simply could not have the right interest in beauty if in his life of soul he were not entangled in a world of hideously ugly spider-like beings.
When they are going through a Gallery, people have no inkling—for what I have said refers only to discovering the form of these beings, who are always present when anyone is delighting in beauty—people have no inkling of how they are strengthened in the interest they take in beautiful pictures by having these hideous spider-like creatures creeping in and out of their ears and nostrils.
Man's enthusiasm for what is beautiful arises on the foundation of ugliness. That is a cosmic secret, my dear friends. The spur of ugliness is needed in order that the beautiful may be made manifest. And the greatest artists were men who because of their strong bodily constitution could endure the invasions of these spidery beings in order to produce, let us say, a Sistine Madonna, or the like. Whatever beauty is brought forth in the world has been lifted out of a sea of ugliness through the enthusiasm in the human soul.
Let it not be thought that behind the veil of the material world, in the region beyond the threshold, we come into a realm of pure beauty. Do not imagine that anyone who is cognizant of these things speaks lightheartedly when he says that if men are not properly prepared they must be held back at the threshold of the spiritual world. For it is essential first of all to know the thoroughly unedifying foundations of all that in front of the curtain as it were, is uplifting and edifying.
Therefore if with spiritual sight we move about the elemental world belonging to air and water, again we see the great battle waging between the fleeting sylphs and undines and these archetypes of ugliness. Although I spoke of the latter as spidery creatures, the tissues of which they are formed are not like those of spiders as we know them, but they are composed of the elements of water and watery vapor. They are volatile air-formations, the ugliness of which is enhanced inasmuch as every second they have a different ugliness; each succeeding ugliness gives the impression of being even worse than its predecessor. This world is present in air and water together with everything that is delightful there.
And now in order that man may unfold enthusiasm for the Good, something else takes place. It can be said of the other beings that they are more or less actually there, but in the case of the beings of whom I am now going to speak it must really be said that they are continually coming into existence, whenever, in fact, a man has within him warmth of feeling for Goodness. It is in this warmth that these beings develop; their nature itself is warm and fiery; they live in the present but their inherent nature is similar to what I have described in the book Occult Science in connection with the Saturn-existence of man.
As man was in the Old Saturn-existence, so are these beings today. Their form is not the same but their nature is similar. It cannot be said of them that they are beautiful or ugly, or anything of that kind; they must be judged in comparison with the ordinary elemental warmth-beings who, as you know, also exist. All spiritual research in this sphere is extraordinarily difficult. It is very difficult to approach the beings who live entirely in warmth, that is to say, in ‘fire’ in the old sense, and when one does come upon them it is not very pleasant. One comes upon them, for instance, when lying in a high fever, but then as a rule one is not a really objective observer. Otherwise it is a matter of developing the requisite faculty for perceiving these warmth-beings by elaborating the methods indicated in my books. These warmth-beings have a certain relationship with the beings who appear, for instance, when a man has warm enthusiasm for the Good, but the relationship is of a very peculiar kind. I will assume hypothetically—for only in that way can I describe these things—that warmth-beings of the normal kind are present, originating in man's physical warmth, which as you know is greater than the warmth of the environment. Man has his own warmth, hence these particular beings are near him. And now, in a man who has enthusiasm for the Good these other beings make themselves manifest; they too are warmth-beings, but of a different kind. When they are in the neighbourhood of the normal fire-beings they immediately draw back from them and slip into the inmost recesses of man's nature. If one then makes great efforts to discover their essential characteristics in contrast to those of the normal warmth-beings, one finds that they have an inner, but very pronounced, bashfulness. They refuse absolutely to be observed by other beings of the spiritual world, and flee from them because they are ashamed of being seen; they flee first and foremost into the inmost nature of man. Hence they are hard to discover. Actually they are only to be discovered if we observe ourselves in certain moments that it is really not so very easy to bring about at will. Just suppose that in spite of not being in the least sentimental we are moved to tears simply by reading a scene in a book that grips us deeply and dramatically. Some great and good action is described, let us say, in a novel. If we have the power of self-observation we can discover how whole hosts of such beings (who have such delicate sensibility that they do not want to be seen by any other beings of the spiritual world) flee into our heart, into our breast, how they come to us, how they seek protection from the other warmth-beings and in fact from any other beings of the elemental spiritual worlds.
There is a significant force of repulsion between the normal warmth-beings and these other warmth beings with their intense bashfulness who live only in the sphere of man's moral life and who flee from contact with other spirit-beings. These beings are present in far greater numbers than is usually imagined and it is they who imbue man with enthusiasm for the morally good. Man would not readily acquire this enthusiasm for the morally good if these beings did not come to his aid; and when a man loves the moral, he has a real bond, an unconscious bond, with these beings.
Certain of their characteristics are such as may lead us to misunderstand this whole kingdom. For after all, why do these beings feel bashful and ashamed? It is actually because all the other beings in the elemental kingdoms of the spiritual world in which they live, disdain them, will have nothing to do with them. They are aware of this and the disdain to which they are subjected causes them to stimulate enthusiasm for the Good.
These beings have certain other characteristics of which I do not care to speak, for the human soul is so obviously upset at any mention of such hideous spidery creatures. I therefore prefer not to refer to certain of their peculiarities. But at any rate we have heard how what unfolds in the realm of the senses as the True, the Beautiful, the Good, unfolds from foundations which need the three spiritual kingdoms I have described, just as we on Earth need the ground on which we walk. These beings do not create the True, the Beautiful or the Good. But the thoughts which express the True, signify the True, need the spirit-dunderheads, so that they may move on their shoulders. The Beautiful that man produces needs the ugly water- and air-spiders so that it can raise itself out of this ocean of ugliness. And the Good needs a kingdom of beings who cannot show themselves at all among the other normal warmth-beings, who must always fight shy of them, and for this very reason evoke enthusiasm for the Good.
If these beings did not exist, then instead of thoughts in our heads we should have, if not exactly leaden soldiers, at least heavy vapors and nothing clever could possibly result. In order to produce the Beautiful we should need to have the gift of imbuing it with actual life in order that men's interest might be aroused. In order that here, in the world of the senses, there may be at hand what we need for the activity of thought, for the sense of beauty, for the will to arouse enthusiasm for the good—for this, three such elemental kingdoms are necessary.
The normal elemental kingdoms—that is, the kingdoms of the gnomes, sylphs, undines and salamanders, to use folk-terminology—are still at the stage of striving to become something in the world. They are on the way to having forms resembling those in our sense-world; the forms will not be the same, but one day they will become perceptible to the senses possessed by men today, whereas now, in their elementary existence, these beings are not perceptible to the ordinary senses.
The beings I have now described to you have in fact already by-passed the stage at which men and animals and plants are today. So that if, for example, we were able to go back to the Old Moon-existence which preceded the Earth, we should there encounter the beings found on Earth today as the bashful beings connected with moral impulses in man. On the Old Moon they would have been perceptible as a real animal world, spinning as it were from tree to tree. But you must call to mind the Old Moon-existence as I have described it in the book Occult Science. Everything in this Moon-existence was pliable and fluid and metamorphosis has continually taken place. Among the beings there, spinning in and out, were those hideous beings I have described, those spidery creatures permeating the Old Moon and visible there. And there were also present the beings who as spirit-fools accompany the wise on the Earth today. They were a factor in bringing about the destruction of the Old Moon, so that the Earth could arise. And even now, during Earth-existence, these beings have no pleasure in the formation of crystals, but rather in the breaking up of everything mineral.
Thus while we can say of the normal elemental beings that they will one day become visible to the senses, we must say of these other beings: once upon a time they were visible to the senses and have now sprung over into the spiritual—admittedly through their Luciferic and Ahrimanic natures. Thus there are two kinds of elemental beings—ascending and descending. We can say: on the ‘dung’ of Old Moon ugliness—which was there in profusion during the Old Moon-existence—on the ‘dung’ of Old Moon ugliness, our world of beauty springs forth.
You have an analogy in Nature when you carry manure to the fields and beautiful plants spring from it. There you have an analogy in Nature except that the dung, the manure, is also perceptible to the senses. So it is when the half-reality of the world of beauty is observed clairvoyantly. Try to envisage this half-real world of beauty, quite apart from the teeming life in the three kingdoms of Nature on the Earth; picture all the beautiful after-effects springing from the Earth. Just as lovely flowers spring up in a meadow, you must spiritually picture underneath it all the Moon-dung which contains the ugly spidery creatures I have described. Just as cabbage does not grow unless it is manured, as little can beauty blossom on the Earth unless the Gods manure the Earth with ugliness. That is the inner necessity of life. And this inner necessity of life must be known to us, for such knowledge alone can give us the power to confront with understanding what actually surrounds us in Nature.
Anyone who believes that beauty in art can be produced on Earth without the foundation of this ugliness is like a man who is horrified that people use manure, insisting that it would be far better to let beautiful things grow without it.—In point of fact it is not possible for beauty to be produced without the foundation of ugliness. And if people do not want to give themselves up to illusion about the world, that is, if they genuinely desire to know the essential and not the illusory, then they must acquire knowledge of these things. Whoever believes that there is art in the world without ugliness does not know what art is. And why not? Simply for the reason that only he who has an inkling of what I have described to you today will enjoy works of art in the right way, for he knows at what cost they are purchased in world-existence. Whoever wants to enjoy works of art without this consciousness is like a man who would prefer to do away with manure on the fields. Such a man has no real knowledge of what grows in Nature; he has, in fact, merely an illusion before him—plants of papier-maché, although real plants are actually there. Whoever does not feel ugliness as the foundation has not the right kind of delight in beauty.
Such is the world-order and men must acquire knowledge of it if they do not want to go on wandering about like earthworms, keeping to their own element and not looking upwards to what is real. Men can only develop the talents latent within them if they confront reality fairly and squarely. Reality, however, is not attained merely by talking time and time again of spirit, spirit, spirit, but by really coming to know the spiritual. But the fact has also to be faced that in certain regions of the spiritual world something like I have been describing to you today will be encountered.
Fünfter Vortrag
Die Fähigkeiten, die der Mensch braucht, um der Welt gegenüberzustehen und in ihr zu arbeiten innerhalb des Erdenlebens, hängen zusammen, wie ich gerade in diesen Zeiten hier gezeigt habe, mit Betätigungen des Menschen in der geistigen Welt, die er zwischen dem Tod und einer neuen Geburt durchmacht. Dadurch ist aber bedingt, daß der Mensch hier auf Erden in gewissen Zusammenhängen darinnensteht, die auf Erden selbst nicht wirklich sind, die ihre Wirklichkeit erst zeigen, wenn man das Ganze im übersinnlichen Gebiete betrachtet.
Nun wollen wir heute von diesem Gesichtspunkte aus unser Augenmerk auf die drei eigentlich alle menschliche Tätigkeit auf der Erde umfassenden Gebiete richten. Wir wollen unser Augenmerk richten auf die Gedanken, durch die der Mensch sich in der Welt die Wahrheit aneignen will, wir wollen unser Augenmerk dann richten auf die Gefühle, insofern sich der Mensch in und durch seine Gefühlswelt das Schöne aneignen will, und wir wollen auf die Willensnatur des Menschen unser Augenmerk richten, insofern der Mensch dutch seine Willensnatur das Gute verwirklichen soll.
Wenn man von Gedanken spricht, so meint man dasjenige Gebiet, durch das sich der Mensch die Wahrheit aneignen kann. Aber Gedanken selbst können nichts Wirkliches sein. Gerade wenn wir uns klar sind darüber, daß wir uns durch unsere Gedanken über die Wahrheit des Wirklichen unterrichten sollen, dann muß auch zugegeben werden, daß Gedanken als solche nichts Wirkliches sein können. Denn nehmen Sie einmal an, Sie würden in Ihren Gedanken so darinnenstecken wie in Ihrem Gehirn oder in Ihrem Herzen, dann würden diese Gedanken selber etwas Wirkliches sein. Sie würden nicht durch diese Gedanken die Wirklichkeit sich aneignen können. Man könnte nicht einmal durch die menschliche Sprache das ausdrücken, was ausgedrückt werden soll, wenn die menschliche Sprache im gewöhnlichen irdischen Sinne eine volle Wirklichkeit enthielte. Wenn wir jedesmal, wenn wir einen Satz sprechen, ein ganz schweres Wirkliches aus dem Munde herausarbeiten müßten, würden wir nicht etwas ausdrücken können, sondern etwas hervorbringen. In diesem Sinne ist das Gesprochene nicht ein Wirkliches selbst, sondern «bedeutet» ein Wirkliches, so wie Gedanken auch nicht selbst ein Wirkliches sind, sondern ein Wirkliches bedeuten.
Wenn wir auf das Gute schauen, dann werden wir finden: dasjenige, was sich durch die physische Wirklichkeit von selber macht, das kann nicht als ein Gutes angesprochen werden. Wir müssen aus der Tiefe unseres Wesens heraus zunächst als ein volles Unwirkliches den Impuls zum Guten holen und ihn dann verwirklichen. Wenn der Impuls zum Guten so auftreten würde wie der Hunger, als ein äußeres Wirkliches, so würde es nicht das Gute sein können.
Und wenn Sie eine Statue ansehen, so kommen Sie nicht auf den Gedanken, daß Sie mit der sich besprechen können. Sie ist ein bloßes Scheingebilde. Im Schein spricht sich etwas aus, was Schönheit ist. So daß wir in der Wahrheit zwar «die Wirklichkeit bedeutet» haben, daß aber die Wahrheit selber in einem unwirklichen Element sich bewegt, ebenso die Schönheit, ebenso die Güte.
Aber so notwendig es für den Menschen ist, daß seine Gedanken nicht selber Wirkliches sind — denken Sie, wenn die Gedanken im Kopfe wie Bleifiguren herumwandern würden, dann würden Sie zwar ein Wirkliches verspüren, aber diese Bleigedanken würden Ihnen nichts bedeuten können, sie wären selber etwas Wirkliches -, so wahr also die Gedanken, so wahr auch das Schöne und das Gute nichts unmittelbar Wirkliches sein können, so wahr ist es dennoch, daß ein Wirkliches notwendig ist in dieser physisch-irdischen Welt, damit wir Gedanken haben können, damit wir das Schöne in der Welt durch die Kunst verwirklichen können, und damit wir auch das Gute verwirklichen können.
Und indem ich dieses bespreche, komme ich heute auf ein Gebiet geisteswissenschaftlicher Betrachtung, das uns recht tief hineinführen kann in dasjenige, was auch auf Erden hier an geistiger Wesenheit um uns herum ist, was sehr nötig ist zu unserem irdischen Dasein, was sich aber der Beobachtung, die den Sinnen möglich ist, eben durchaus entzieht und daher auch vom gewöhnlichen Bewußtsein, das sich nur auf die sinnliche Wahrnehmung stützt, nicht gedacht werden kann. Wir sind überall umgeben in Wahrheit von geistigen Wesen der verschiedensten Art, nur daß das gewöhnliche Bewußtsein diese geistigen Wesen nicht sieht. Aber sie sind notwendig, damit wir als Menschen unsere Tätigkeiten entfalten können, damit wir die Gedanken in ihrer unwirklichen Leichtigkeit und Flüchtigkeit haben können, so daß sie nicht selbst wie Bleigewichte in unserem Kopfe vorhanden sind, nicht selbst etwas sind, sondern etwas bedeuten können. Dazu ist notwendig, daß in der Welt Wesen vorhanden sind, welche verursachen, daß unsere Gedanken mit ihrer Unwirklichkeit uns nicht fortwährend gleich entschwinden. Wir Menschen sind eigentlich mit dem gewöhnlichen Bewußtsein, ich möchte sagen zu schwerhaltige Wesen, zu plumpe Wesen, als daß wir so ohne weiteres mit diesem gewöhnlichen Bewußtsein die Gedanken festhalten könnten, und es müssen Elementarwesen da sein, die uns fortwährend helfen, unsere Gedanken festzuhalten. Solche Elementarwesen sind auch da, nur sind sie außerordentlich schwer zu entdecken, weil sie, ich möchte sagen, sich fortdauernd verstecken.
Wenn man sich fragt: Wodurch kommt es denn eigentlich, daß man einen Gedanken festhalten kann, trotzdem er gar kein Wirkliches ist, wer hilft einem dabei? — dann wird man sehr leicht gerade bei der geisteswissenschaftlichen Anschauung getäuscht. Denn in demselben Momente, wo man sich darauf verlegt, zu fragen: Wer hält die Gedanken für den Menschen fest? — wird man schon durch diese Tendenz, von den geistigen Wesenhaftigkeiten wissen zu wollen, welche die Gedanken festhalten, in das Reich der ahrimanischen Wesenheiten hineingetrieben. Und man taucht unter in das Reich der ahrimanischen Wesenheiten und beginnt sehr bald zu glauben — aber es ist ein täuschender Glaube -, daß man von den ahrimanischen Geistern unterstützt werden muß, um die Gedanken festzuhalten, damit sie einem nicht gleich, wenn man sie faßt, entschwinden. Daher sind auch die meisten Menschen unbewußt den ahrimanischen Wesenheiten sogar dankbar dafür, daß sie sie in ihrem Denken unterstützen. Aber es ist eigentlich ein schlecht angebrachter Dank, denn es gibt ein ganzes Reich von Wesenheiten, welche uns gerade in bezug auf unsere Gedankenwelt unterstützen und die durchaus nicht ahrimanischer Wesenheit sind.
Diese Wesenheiten sind auch für das schon vorgerückte Schauen in der geistigen Welt schwer zu entdecken. Man findet sie zuweilen, wenn man zum Beispiel einen sehr gescheiten Menschen in seinem Tun und Treiben beobachtet. Wenn man nämlich in seinem Tun und Treiben einen sehr gescheiten Menschen beobachtet, dann hat eigentlich dieser Mensch eine flüchtige Gefolgschaft. Er geht eigentlich nirgends allein herum, sondern er hat eine flüchtige Gefolgschaft von geistigen Wesenheiten, die nicht dem ahrimanischen Reich angehören, die aber eine ganz merkwürdige Eigenschaft haben, die man eigentlich erst kennenlernt, wenn man jene Wesenheiten beobachten kann, welche den elementarischen Reichen angehören, die also nicht für die sinnlichen Augen erscheinen, die sich betätigen, wenn Formen in der Natur, Kristallformen zum Beispiel und dergleichen, entstehen. Alles Formhafte unterliegt ja der Tätigkeit dieser Wesenheiten, die Sie auch in meinen Mysterien in ihrer Tätigkeit als Wesenheiten geschildert finden, die feste Formen prägen und hämmern. Wenn Sie in dem einen Mysterienspiel die gnomenartigen Wesen verfolgen, so haben Sie da diese Wesen, welche Formen hervorbringen. Nun sind - wie Sie das schon aus der Art und Weise, wie ich das in meinen Mysteriendramen dargestellt habe, ersehen können — diese Wesenheiten schlau, und aus ihrer Schlauheit heraus spotten sie über den geringen Verstand, den die Menschen haben. Vergegenwärtigen Sie sich diese Szene, wenn Sie sie aus meinem Mysterienspiel kennen.
Wenn man nun einen wirklich gescheiten Menschen verfolgt, wie er in seinem Gefolge ein ganzes Heer solcher Wesenheiten haben kann, wie ich vorhin gesagt habe, so findet man, daß diese Wesenheiten außerordentlich geringgeachtet werden von den Gnomengeistern der elementarischen Welt, weil sie plump sind, und vor allen Dingen, weil sie furchtbar töricht sind. Das Törichte ist ihre hauptsächlichste Eigenschaft. Und so kann man sagen: Gerade gescheiteste Leute in der Welt, wenn man sie daraufhin beobachten kann, werden von ganzen Trupps von Toren verfolgt aus der geistigen Welt. - Es ist, wie wenn diese Toren zu einem gehören wollten. Und diese Toren werden, wie gesagt, außerordentlich geringgeachtet von den Wesenheiten, welche Formen in der Natur verfertigen in der in den Mystetien geschilderten Weise. So daß man sagen kann: In den Welten, die zunächst dem gewöhnlichen Bewußtsein unbekannt sind, ist eine, die von einem Volk, von einem Geistervolk von Toren bevölkert ist, von Toren, die sich insbesondere zur menschlichen Weisheit und Klugheit hindrängen.
Diese Wesen haben im gegenwärtigen Zeitalter eigentlich kein eigenes Leben. Sie kommen dadurch zu einem Leben, daß sie das Leben derjenigen benutzen, welche sterben, welche durch Krankheiten sterben, aber noch Lebenskräfte in sich haben. Vergangenes Leben nur können sie benutzen. Es sind also Geistertoren, welche das Leben, das von Menschen übrigbleibt, benützen, die also sozusagen sich vollsaugen von dem, was von übrigbleibendem Leben noch an Kirchhöfen und dergleichen aufsteigt.
Gerade wenn man eindringt in solche Welten, dann bekommt man einen Begriff, wie unendlich stark die Welt, die hinter der menschlichen Sinneswelt ist, bevölkert ist, und wie mannigfaltig die Klassen von solchen geistigen Wesenheiten sind, und wie diese geistigen Wesenheiten durchaus im Zusammenhang mit unseren Fähigkeiten stehen. Denn der gescheite Mensch, den man da in seiner Tätigkeit verfolgt, kann, wenn er nicht hellsichtig, sondern bloß gescheit ist, seine gescheiten Gedanken gerade dadurch besonders festhalten, daß er von diesem Troß von geistigen Toren verfolgt ist. Die klammern sich an seine Gedanken, zerren sie und geben ihnen Gewicht, so daß sie bei ihm bleiben, während er sonst dieGedanken rasch verschwinden haben würde.
Diese Wesenheiten werden also außerordentlich stark verspottet von den gnomenhaften Wesenheiten. Die gnomenhaften Wesenheiten wollen sie in ihrem Reiche nicht dulden, aber sie gehören demselben Reiche an. Sie vertreiben sie fortwährend, und es ist ein harter Kampf zwischen dem Gnomenvolke und diesem Volke von geistigen Toren, die eigentlich erst dem Menschen die Weisheit möglich machen, denn sonst wäre die Weisheit flüchtig, würde in dem Moment vergehen, wo sie entsteht, könnte nicht bleiben. Wie gesagt, sie sind schwer zu entdecken, diese Wesenheiten, weil man sehr leicht sofort ins Ahrimanische hinunterkollert, wenn man die entsprechende Frage aufstellt. Aber man kann sie bei solchen Gelegenheiten finden, wie ich sie angedeutet habe, durch Verfolgen besonders gescheiter Menschen, die einen ganzen Troß von solchen Wesenheiten hinter sich haben. Außerdem aber, wenn nicht genug gescheite Gedanken da sind, die am Menschen haften, findet man diese Wesenheiten auf allerlei Denkmälern der Weisheit. Sie halten sich zum Beispiel - aber sie sind dort auch schwer zu finden - in Bibliotheken auf, wenn etwas Gescheites in den Büchern darinnensteht. Wenn in den Büchern Dummes steht, dann sind diese Wesenheiten nicht zu finden, sie sind eben nur dort zu finden, wo Gescheites ist; daran klammern sie sich.
Wir gewinnen da gewissermaßen Einblick in ein Reich, das uns durchaus umgibt, das wie die Naturreiche vorhanden ist, und das mit unseren eigenen Fähigkeiten etwas zu tun hat, das aber auch von uns schwer zu beurteilen ist. Daher muß man sich, wenn man es beurteilen will, schon auf diese gnomenhaften Wesen verlassen und auf ihre Aussagen etwas geben, und die finden sie außerordentlich dumm und frech. Aber sie haben noch eine Eigenschaft, diese Wesen. Wenn sie gar zu sehr von den Naturgeistern gnomenhafter Art verfolgt werden, dann flüchten sie sich in die menschlichen Köpfe, und während sie eigentlich draußen in der Natur fast Riesen sind — sie sind nämlich außerordentlich groß -, werden sie ganz klein, wenn sie in den menschlichen Köpfen sind. Man könnte sagen, daß sie eine Art abnormer Naturgeister sind, die aber mit der ganzen menschlichen Entwickelung auf der Erde innig zusammenhängen.
Eine andere Art ist diejenige, welche vorzugsweise im wäßrigen und luftförmigen Elemente lebt, so wie jene Wesenheiten, die Sie in den angedeuteten Mysteriendramen als die sylphenartigen Wesenheiten und so weiter von mir geschildert finden. Diese Wesenheiten, die ich jetzt meine, haben es vorzugsweise mit der Welt des Scheines, des schönen Scheines zu tun, sie hängen sich weniger an die gescheiten Leute als an die künstlerischen Naturen an. Aber auch sie sind wiederum sehr schwer zu entdecken, weil sie sich leicht verstecken können. Sie sind da zu finden, wo wirkliche Kunstwerke sind, wo also im Scheine vorhanden ist die menschliche Gestalt oder natürliche Gestalten oder dergleichen. Da sind sie zu finden. Diese Wesenheiten können wir, wie gesagt, auch wieder nur schwer entdecken. Wenn wir uns nämlich fragen: Wie kommt es, daß der schöne Schein uns interessiert, daß wir unter Umständen ein größeres Vergnügen an einer schönen Statue haben als an einem lebendigen Menschen - allerdings ein Vergnügen anderer Art, aber eben größeres Vergnügen -, oder daß wir uns an der melodischen oder harmonischen Ausgestaltung von Tönen erbauen und erfreuen? — so kollern wir wieder sehr leicht in ein anderes Reich hinein, in das Reich der luziferischen Wesenheiten. Aber es sind nicht nur die luziferischen Wesenheiten, welche das Künstlerische tragen, sondern wiederum ein solches Reich von elementarischen Wesenheiten, welche den Menschen, der sonst immer geneigt sein würde, dem künstlerisch schönen Scheine gegenüber kein Interesse zu haben, weil er unwirklich ist, in diesem Interesse wachhalten, welche überhaupt das künstlerische Interesse anregen.
Nun ist es deshalb so schwierig, diese Wesenheiten zu entdecken, weil sie sich noch leichter als die Toren in der Geisterwelt verstecken können, denn sie sind eigentlich nur da, wo das Schöne sich geltend macht. Und wenn man dem Schönen hingegeben ist, wenn man das Schöne genießt, dann sieht man diese Wesen ganz gewiß nicht. Warum?
Man muß tatsächlich, um dieser Wesen auf eine normale Weise ansichtig zu werden, versuchen, wenn man irgendwie künstlerischen Eindrücken hingegeben ist, den hellseherischen Blick auf diejenigen Wesenheiten zu richten, die Sie in derselben Szene als nymphen- oder sylphenartige Wesen geschildert finden, die auch in den Elementarreichen der Natur vorhanden sind, und man muß sich in diese hineinversetzen. Man muß gewissermaßen mit diesen Luft- und Wasserwesen die andern anschauen, die da vorhanden sind im Genusse des Schönen. Und da das schwer ist, so muß man sich noch auf eine andere Weise helfen. Nun, zum Glück, möchte ich sagen, kann man diese Wesen dann leicht entdecken, wenn man irgend jemandem zuhört, der ziemlich schön spricht und dessen Sprache man nicht ordentlich versteht, wo man nur die Laute hört, ohne daß man sie in ihrer Bedeutung versteht. Wenn man sich dem hingibt, diesem Schön-Sprechen — aber es muß schön gesprochen sein, es muß oratorisch gesprochen sein, und man muß es doch nicht ordentlich verstehen -, dann kann man sich die Fähigkeit aneignen, es ist eine intime, zarte Fähigkeit, diese Wesenheiten zu sehen. Also man muß sozusagen versuchen, das Talent der Sylphen sich anzueignen und es zu verstärken durch jenes Talent, das sich dann ausbildet, wenn man Reden zuhört, die schön gesprochen werden und die man nicht versteht, wobei man auch nicht hinhört auf das, was sie bedeuten sollen, sondern nur auf das schöne Sprechen. Dann entdeckt man diese Wesenheiten, welche überall da sind, wo das Schöne ist, und ihre Unterstützung gewähren, so daß der Mensch das rechte Interesse an dem Schönen haben kann.
Und dann folgt das große Enttäuschtsein, dann folgt das große furchtbare Erstaunen. Diese Wesen sind nämlich urhäßlich, das Häßlichste, was man entdecken kann, schauderhafte Wesen, die Urbilder der Häßlichkeit. Und hat man einmal sich den geistigen Blick für diese Wesen angeeignet und besucht dann mit diesem geistigen Blick irgendein Atelier, in dem Künstlerisches geschaffen wird, dann findet man, daß es diese Wesenheiten sind, die wie Spinnen eigentlich auf dem Grunde des Weltendaseins auf Erden sind, damit der Mensch an der Schönheit Interesse hat. Diese schauderhaften Spinnenwesen elementarischer Art sind es, dutch die das Interesse an der Schönheit gerade wach wird. Der Mensch würde gar nicht das richtige Interesse an der Schönheit haben können, wenn er nicht mit seiner Seele in eine Welt von urhäßlichen Spinnenwesen eingesponnen wäre.
Man ahnt gar nicht, wenn man so durch eine Galerie geht - denn das, was ich erzählt habe, ist alles nur zum Entdecken der Formen dieser Wesenheiten, sie sind jedesmal da, wenn der Mensch das Schöne genießt —, wie man in seinem Interesse für die schönsten Bilder dadurch unterstützt wird, daß in allen Ohren und in allen Nasenlöchern diese häßlichsten Spinnen aus- und einkriechen. Auf dem Grunde der Häßlichkeit erhebt sich des Menschen Begeisterung für die Schönheit. Das ist ein Weltengeheimnis. Man braucht, ich möchte sagen, die Aufstachelung durch das Häßliche, damit gerade das Schöne zum Vorschein kommt. Und die großen künstlerischen Naturen waren solche, die durch ihre starke Leiblichkeit das Durchsetztsein mit diesen Spinnen ertragen konnten, um eine Sixtinische Madonna oder dergleichen hervorzubringen. Was in der Welt an Schönem hervorgebracht wird, wird eben durchaus so hervorgebracht, daß es sich aus einem Meere von Häßlichkeit durch den Enthusiasmus der menschlichen Seele heraushebt.
Man darf nicht glauben, daß, wenn man hinter den Schleier des Sinnlichen kommt, wenn man an das Gebiet jenseits der Schwelle kommt, man da in lauter Schönes kommt. Glauben Sie nicht, daß von irgend jemandem, der diese Dinge kennt, es etwa leichtsinnig ausgesprochen ist, wenn er sagt: Die Menschen müssen, wenn sie nicht ordentlich vorbereitet sind, an der Schwelle der geistigen Welt zurückgehalten werden. - Denn zunächst muß man für alles, was man als das Erhebende und Erbauende gewissermaßen vor dem Vorhang hat, kennenlernen die durchaus nicht erbaulichen Untergründe. Und wenn Sie daher in der elementarischen Welt, die der Luft und dem Wasser angehört, sich schauend ergehen, dann sehen Sie wiederum den großen Kampf der flüchtigen Sylphenwelt und Undinsnwelt gegenüber diesen Urbildern der Häßlichkeit. Ich sage Spinnentiete; sie bestehen nicht aus dem Spinnengewebe, sondern sie sind aus dem Elemente des Wassers und aus dem Elemente des Wasserdunstes gebaut. Sie sind flüchtig gestaltete Luftgestalten, die ihre Häßlichkeit noch dadurch erhöhen, daß sie in jeder Sekunde eine andere Häßlichkeit haben, wodurch man immer das Gefühl hat, jede nächstfolgende Häßlichkeit, die auf eine vorhergehende aufgesetzt wird, ist noch größer als die vorhergehende. Das ist die Welt, welche ebenso in der Luft und im Wasser vorhanden ist wie dasjenige, was erfreulich ist in Luft und Wasser.
Und damit der Mensch den Enthusiasmus für das Gute entwickeln kann, findet noch ein anderes statt. Bei den andern Wesen kann man sagen, sie sind mehr oder weniger da, aber bei den Wesenheiten, von denen ich jetzt sprechen will, muß man eigentlich sagen, sie entwickeln sich fortwährend, und zwar entwickeln sie sich gerade dann, wenn der Mensch eine gewisse innere Wärme für das Gute hat. Da entwickeln sich in dieser Wärme jene Wesenheiten, die nun feuriger, warmer Natur sind, Wesenheiten, die in der Gegenwart leben, die aber eigentlich eine solche Natur haben, wie ich sie in meiner «Geheimwissenschaft im Umriß» für das Saturndasein des Menschen beschrieben habe.
So wie der Mensch im alten Saturndasein war, so sind diese Wesenheiten heute. Nur sind sie nicht so gestaltet wie der Mensch, aber sie haben solch eine Natur. Man kann von ihnen nicht sagen, daß sie schön oder häßlich sind oder dergleichen; man muß sie beurteilen von dem Gesichtspunkte aus, der einem von den gewöhnlichen elementarischen Wärmewesen gegeben wird, die auch vorhanden sind. Die ganze geistige Untersuchung ist außerordentlich schwer, denn man kommt an diese Wesenheiten, die bloß in der Wärme, also — im alten Sinne gesprochen - im «Feuer» leben, man kommt als Mensch außerordentlich schwer an sie heran, und wenn man herankommt, so ist es nicht angenehm. Man kommt zum Beispiel heran, wenn man im heftigen Fieber liegt. Aber da ist man in der Regel kein sehr objektiver Beobachter. Sonst handelt es sich darum, daß man sich durch die weitere Ausbildung der Mittel, die in meinen Büchern angegeben sind, die Anschauung für solche Wärmewesen entwickelt. Aber diese Wärmewesen haben schon ein gewisses Verhältnis zu jenen Wesenheiten, die namentlich dann erscheinen, wenn der Mensch einen warmen Enthusiasmus für das Gute entwickelt. Aber das Verhältnis ist ganz eigentümlicher Art.
Ich will hypothetisch annehmen - denn nur so kann ich eigentlich die Sache schildern -, es seien solche Wärmewesen normaler Art da, die überhaupt von der menschlichen physischen Wärme herrühren, die ja größer ist als die Wärme der Umgebung. Der Mensch hat Eigenwärme. Dadurch sind in seiner Nähe diese Wesenheiten. Und nun werden in einem Menschen, der für das Gute enthusiasmiert ist, diese andern Wesenheiten, die auch Wärmewesen, aber anderer Art sind, hervorgebracht. Wenn sie aber in der Nähe der normalen Feuerwesen sind, ziehen sie sich gleich vor ihnen zurück und schlüpfen in das Innerste des Menschen hinein. Wenn man sich nämlich viel Mühe gibt, vom Standpunkt der normalen Wärmewesen aus die Eigenschaften dieser Wesenheiten zu entdecken, dann findet man: diese Wesenheiten haben ein intimes, aber furchtbar stark ausgebildetes Schamgefühl. Sie wollen absolut nicht beobachtet werden von andern Wesen der geistigen Welt und fliehen vor ihnen, weil sie sich schämen, gesehen zu werden, fliehen vor allen Dingen in das Innerste der Menschen hinein, so daß sie schwer zu entdecken sind. Sie sind eigentlich nur zu entdecken, wenn man, sagen wir, sich selbst beobachtet in gewissen Momenten, die man eigentlich willkürlich nicht so leicht herbeiführen kann. Nehmen Sie einmal an, Sie lesen irgend etwas und werden einfach dadurch, daß Sie eine Szene lesen, die Sie dramatisch sehr ergreift, ohne daß Sie ein sentimentaler Mensch sind, zu Tränen gerührt. Irgendeine große, gute Handlung, meinetwillen im Roman, wird geschildert, Sie werden bis zu Tränen gerührt. Wenn Sie dann Selbstbeobachtung haben, da können Sie entdecken, wie ganze Scharen solcher Wesenheiten — die ein so fein und intim ausgebildetes Schamgefühl haben, daß sie von allen anderen Wesen der geistigen Welt nicht gesehen sein wollen - sich in Ihr Herz, überhaupt in Ihre ganze innere Brust hineinflüchten, wie sie zu Ihnen kommen, wie sie Schutz suchen vor den andern Wesen der elementarisch-geistigen Welten und namentlich vor den andern Wärmewesen.
Es ist eine bedeutsame Abstoßungskraft zwischen den normalen Wärmewesen und diesen mit so außerordentlich starkem Schamgefühl ausgestatteten Wärmewesen, die nur in der moralischen Sphäre der Menschen leben und sich vor der Berührung mit andern Geistwesen flüchten. Diese Wesenheiten sind in viel größerer Anzahl vorhanden, als man gewöhnlich meint, und sie sind es, die gerade den Menschen mit dem Enthusiasmus für das moralisch Gute ausgestalten. Der Mensch würde nicht leicht diesen Enthusiasmus für das moralisch Gute bekommen, wenn diese Wesenheiten ihm nicht zu Hilfe kämen. Und wenn der Mensch das Moralische liebt, dann steht er eigentlich im Bunde, im unbewußten Bunde mit diesen Wesenheiten.
Gewisse Eigenschaften dieser Wesenheiten sind durchaus so, daß man leicht dieses ganze Reich mißverstehen kann. Denn in der Tat, warum schämen sich denn diese Wesen? Sie schämen sich wirklich aus dem Grunde, weil die ganze übrige geistige Welt des Elementarreiches, in dem diese Wesenheiten sind, sie eigentlich verachtet, nichts wissen will von ihnen. Und das spüren diese Wesenheiten, und dadurch, daß sie so verachtete Wesenheiten sind, wirken sie gerade zum Enthusiasmus für das Gute.
Gewisse andere Eigenschaften dieser Wesenheiten möchte ich gar nicht gerne berühren, weil man schon sehen kann, wie eigentümlich die Menschenseele berührt wird, wenn man von den urhäßlichen Spinnenwesen berichtet. Deshalb möchte ich gewisse Eigenschaften dieser Wesenheiten unberührt lassen. Aber wir haben gesehen, wie dasjenige, was sich hier im Reiche des Sinnenwesens entwickelt als das Wahre, das Schöne, das Gute, sich durchaus herausentwickelt aus Grundlagen, die diese drei geistigen Reiche, die ich geschildert habe, brauchen, so wie wir als Menschen auf Erden den Boden brauchen, auf dem wir gehen. Nicht, als ob diese Wesenheiten das Wahre, Schöne und Gute erzeugen würden, das tun sie nicht. Aber die Gedanken, die das Wahre ausdrücken, die das Wahre bedeuten, brauchen die geistigen Dummköpfe, damit sie sich auf ihren Schultern bewegen können. Und das Schöne, das der Mensch hervorbringt, braucht die häßlichen Wasser- und Luftspinnen, damit es sich aus diesem Meere von Häßlichkeit erheben kann. Und das Gute braucht ein Reich von Wesenheiten, das sich gar nicht unter den andern anständigen Wärmewesen zeigen kann, das sich immer scheuen muß, und das gerade dadurch den Enthusiasmus für die Impulse des Guten hervorruft.
Wenn all diese Wesen nicht wären, dann müßten wir statt unserer Gedanken im Kopfe, wenn auch nicht gerade bleierne Soldaten, so wenigstens schwere Dünste haben. Es würden nicht sehr gescheite Dinge sein, die dabei herauskämen. Und um das Schöne hervorzubringen, müßten wir schon die Gabe haben, dieses Schöne auch ein wenig lebendig zu machen, damit die Menschen Interesse daran hätten und so weiter. Damit hier im Reiche der Sinnenwelt dasjenige vorhanden ist, was wir brauchen für unsere Gedankentätigkeit, für unsere Gefühlstätigkeit im Schönen, für unsere Willenstätigkeit im Guten, dazu sind drei solche elementarische Reiche notwendig.
Wenn wir die normalen elementarischen Reiche betrachten, also wenn wir uns des volkstümlichen Ausdruckes bedienen — die Reiche der Gnomen, Sylphen, Undinen, Salamander, so haben wir in ihnen eigentlich Reiche, die erst noch etwas in der Welt werden wollen. Sie gehen ähnlichen Gestaltungen entgegen, die wir in unserer Sinnenwelt haben, nur anders werden sie sein, aber sie werden für solche Sinne, wie die Menschen sie heute haben, einmal wahrnehmbar werden, während sie heute in ihrem elementaren Dasein nicht für die gewöhnlichen Sinne wahrnehmbar sind.
Die Wesenheiten aber, welche ich Ihnen jetzt geschildert habe, sind über die Stufe, die heute Menschen und Tiere oder Pflanzen haben, schon hinübergeschnappt, sind weiter als diese, sind schon hinübergeschnappt. So daß wir, wenn wir zum Beispiel zum alten Mondenwesen zurückgehen könnten, das dem Erdendasein vorangegangen ist, wir dort diese Wesenheiten finden würden, die wir heute hier als jene schamhaft moralisch anspornenden Wesenheiten auf Erden finden. Die würden wir auf dem alten Monde als richtige 'Tierwelt, die auch für irdische Augen sichtbar wäre, sich so herumspinnen sehen, so von Baum zu Baum, sagen wit. Aber Sie müssen sich das Mondendasein ins Gedächtnis rufen, wie ich es geschildert habe in meiner «Geheimwissenschaft». Dieses Mondendasein ist natürlich ein weiches und flüchtiges, und die Dinge metamorphosieren sich, bilden sich um. Und zwischen diesen Wesenheiten, da spinnen sich hin dann jene häßlichen Wesen, die ich geschildert habe, diese Urspinnen, von denen der alte Mond ganz durchsetzt war und die da sichtbar waren. Und dann waren auch vorhanden jene Wesenheiten, die heute als die Dummköpfe den Weisen begleiten. Die waren dort vorhanden, und sie haben es bewirkt, daß der alte Mond zerstoben ist, so daß die Erde daraus werden konnte. Auch hier noch während des Erdendaseins haben diese Wesenheiten keine Freude an der Entstehung der Kristalle, aber an allem Zerhacken des Mineralischen.
Also während wir von den andern, normalen Elementarwesen sagen können, sie werden einmal sichtbar, sinnenfällig wahrnehmbar werden, müssen wir von diesen Wesenheiten sagen, sie waren einmal sinnenfällig wahrnehmbar und sind allerdings nun durch ahrimanische und luziferische Geistigkeit ins Geistige herübergeschnappt. So daß wir also zweierlei Arten von elementarischen Wesen haben, eine aufsteigende und eine absteigende Art. Und ich möchte sagen: Auf dem Moder der alten Mondenhäßlichkeit — denn die war reichlich während des alten Mondendaseins vorhanden — erwächst unsere Welt der Schönheit.
Sie haben ein Analogon in der Natur, wenn Sie den Mist, den Dünger auf die Äcker hinausführen, und dann daraus die schönsten Pflanzen erblühen. Da haben Sie das Analogon der Natur, nur daß da Ihnen auch der Dünger, der Mist sinnlich entgegentritt. So ist es, wenn man dasjenige geistig betrachtet, was nur halb wirklich ist als Welt des Schönen. Dieses, was nur halb wirklich ist als Welt des Schönen, lassen Sie es vor sich stehen, ohne Rücksicht zu nehmen darauf, was sonst lebendig in den drei Reichen der Natur auf der Erde wimmelt, lassen Sie meinetwillen vor Ihrem Geiste auftauchen alles das, was an schönen Nachwirkungen aus der Erde hervorsprießt. Jedenfalls, wie auf einer Wiese die schönsten Blumen hervorsprießen, so müssen Sie sich darunter jenen Moder, jenen Dünger, den Mondendünger geistig denken, der diese häßlichen Spinnen, die ich geschildert habe, enthält. So wie Ihnen Ihr Kohl nicht wächst, ohne daß Sie misten, ebensowenig kann Schönheit auf der Erde erblühen, ohne daß die Götter die Erde mit Häßlichkeit düngen. Das ist die innere Notwendigkeit des Lebens, und diese innere Notwendigkeit des Lebens muß man kennen, denn die gibt allein die Fähigkeit, wissend gegenüberzustehen dem, was eigentlich in der Natur uns umgibt.
Wer glaubt, daß auf Erden die Schönheit in der Kunst hervorgebracht werden kann ohne die Grundlage dieser Häßlichkeit, gleicht einem Menschen, der sagt: Es ist aber doch eigentlich schauderhaft, daß die Leute düngen, sie sollen doch lieber die schönen Dinge wachsen lassen ohne Mist. — Es ist eben nicht möglich, daß die Schönheit hervorgebracht wird ohne die Grundlage der Häßlichkeit. Und will man sich nicht Illusionen über die Welt hingeben, das heißt, will man wahrhaftig erkennen das Wirkliche und nicht das Illusorische, dann muß man diese Dinge erkennen. Das ist schon notwendig. Wer da glaubt, daß in der Welt die Kunst ist ohne die Häßlichkeit, der kennt die Kunst auch nicht. Warum nicht? Nun, einfach aus dem Grunde, weil nur derjenige, der eine Ahnung hat von dem, was ich Ihnen heute geschildert habe, erst in der richtigen Weise die Kunstwerke genießen wird, denn er weiß, um was sie im Weltendasein erkauft sind. Und wer Kunstwerke genießen will ohne dieses Bewußtsein, der gleicht eigentlich einem Menschen, der das Düngen der Äcker abschaffen möchte. Er kennt dann nicht das, was in der Natur wächst, sondern er hat in Wirklichkeit nur die Illusion vor sich, gewissermaßen Pflanzen aus Papiermaché. Wenn er auch wirkliche Pflanzen hat, hat er nur Pflanzen aus Papiermaché! Wer die Häßlichkeit nicht in seinen Untergründen fühlt, hat nicht das rechte Entzücken an der Schönheit.
So ist es in der Welt eingerichtet. Und das ist es, was die Menschheit lernen muß, wenn sie nicht weiter durch die Welt wandern will ich habe es schon einmal gesagt — wie eben die Regenwürmer, die auch an ihrem Element haften und nicht aufschauen zu dem, was wirklich ist. Die Menschen können aber das, was in ihnen liegt an Anlagen, nur entwickeln, wenn sie sich der Wirklichkeit gegenüberstellen. Die Wirklichkeit aber ist nicht damit gegeben, daß man nur redet von Geist, Geist, Geist, sondern daß man die geistige Welt wirklich kennenlernt. Dann aber muß man auch sich aussetzen dem, daß unter Umständen in gewissen Gebieten der geistigen Welt so etwas zutage tritt, wie ich es Ihnen heute geschildert habe.
Fifth Lecture
The abilities which man needs in order to face the world and to work in it within earthly life are connected, as I have just shown here in these times, with man's activities in the spiritual world, which he goes through between death and a new birth. This, however, means that the human being here on earth stands in certain contexts which are not real on earth itself, which only show their reality when one looks at the whole in the supersensible realm.
Now we want to direct our attention today from this point of view to the three areas that actually encompass all human activity on earth. We want to direct our attention to thoughts, through which man wants to acquire truth in the world, we want to direct our attention to feelings, insofar as man wants to acquire the beautiful in and through his emotional world, and we want to direct our attention to the will nature of man, insofar as man is to realize the good through his will nature.
When we speak of thoughts, we mean the area through which man can acquire the truth. But thoughts themselves cannot be something real. Just when we are clear about the fact that we are to inform ourselves through our thoughts about the truth of the real, then it must also be admitted that thoughts as such cannot be anything real. For suppose you were as much in your thoughts as in your brain or in your heart, then these thoughts themselves would be something real. You would not be able to acquire reality through these thoughts. You could not even express through human language what is to be expressed, if human language in the ordinary earthly sense contained a full reality. If every time we spoke a sentence we had to work out a very difficult reality from our mouths, we would not be able to express something, but would produce something. In this sense, what is spoken is not a real thing itself, but “signifies” a real thing, just as thoughts are not themselves a real thing, but signify a real thing.
If we look at the good, we will find that what is produced by physical reality cannot be addressed as a good. We must first draw the impulse to good from the depths of our being as a fully unreal thing and then realize it. If the impulse towards the good were to appear like hunger, as an external reality, it could not be the good.
And when you look at a statue, you don't get the idea that you can talk to it. It is a mere illusion. Appearance expresses something that is beauty. So that in truth we have indeed “signified reality”, but that truth itself moves in an unreal element, as does beauty, as does goodness.
But as necessary as it is for man that his thoughts are not themselves real things - think, if thoughts were to wander about in your head like figures of lead, you would indeed feel a real thing, but these lead thoughts would not be able to mean anything to you, they would themselves be something real - so true are thoughts, as true as the beautiful and the good cannot be something directly real, it is nevertheless true that a real is necessary in this physical-earthly world so that we can have thoughts, so that we can realize the beautiful in the world through art, and so that we can also realize the good.
And by discussing this I come today to an area of spiritual-scientific observation which can lead us quite deeply into that what is also here on earth around us in spiritual entity, what is very necessary for our earthly existence, but what just completely eludes observation, which is possible for the senses, and therefore also cannot be thought by the ordinary consciousness, which only relies on sensual perception. In truth, we are surrounded everywhere by spiritual beings of the most varied kinds, except that ordinary consciousness does not see these spiritual beings. But they are necessary so that we as human beings can develop our activities, so that we can have thoughts in their unreal lightness and fleetingness, so that they are not themselves like lead weights in our heads, are not themselves something, but can mean something. For this it is necessary that there should be beings in the world who cause our thoughts, with their unreality, not to continually disappear from us. We human beings are actually with our ordinary consciousness, I would like to say, too heavy beings, too clumsy beings, to be able to hold on to our thoughts so easily with this ordinary consciousness, and there must be elemental beings who constantly help us to hold on to our thoughts. Such elemental beings are also there, but they are extremely difficult to discover because, I would say, they are constantly hiding.
If you ask yourself: How is it that you can hold on to a thought even though it is not real, who helps you to do so? - then one is very easily deceived, especially in the spiritual-scientific view. For at the very moment when one sets out to ask: Who holds the thoughts for man? - one is already driven into the realm of the ahrimanic entities by this tendency to want to know about the spiritual entities that hold the thoughts. And one dives into the realm of the ahrimanic entities and very soon begins to believe - but it is a deceptive belief - that one must be supported by the ahrimanic spirits in order to hold on to the thoughts so that they do not vanish as soon as one grasps them. That is why most people are unconsciously grateful to the ahrimanic entities for supporting them in their thinking. But it is actually an ill-placed gratitude, because there is a whole realm of entities which support us precisely in relation to our world of thought and which are not at all of Ahrimanic nature.
These beings are also difficult to discover for the already advanced seeing in the spiritual world. They can sometimes be found, for example, if you observe a very clever person in his activities. If you observe a very clever person in his activities, then this person actually has a fleeting following. He does not actually go about anywhere alone, but has a fleeting following of spiritual beings who do not belong to the ahrimanic realm, but who have a very strange characteristic which you only really get to know when you can observe those beings who belong to the elementary realms, who therefore do not appear to the sensual eyes, who are active when forms arise in nature, crystal forms for example and the like. All form is subject to the activity of these entities, which you will also find described in my Mysteries as entities that shape and hammer solid forms. If you follow the gnome-like beings in the one mystery play, you have these beings which produce forms. Now, as you can already see from the way I have portrayed this in my mystery dramas, these beings are clever, and out of their cleverness they mock the poor intellect that humans have. Visualize this scene if you know it from my mystery play.
If you now follow a really clever person, as he can have a whole army of such beings in his entourage, as I said earlier, you will find that these beings are extremely disregarded by the gnome spirits of the elemental world because they are clumsy and, above all, because they are terribly foolish. Foolishness is their main characteristic. And so it can be said that the cleverest people in the world, if they can be observed, are pursued by whole troops of fools from the spiritual world. - It is as if these fools wanted to belong to you. And these fools are, as I said, extremely disregarded by the beings who produce forms in nature in the way described in the Mystetia. So that one can say: In the worlds which are at first unknown to ordinary consciousness, there is one which is peopled by a people, by a spirit-people of fools, by fools who push themselves especially towards human wisdom and prudence.
These beings have no life of their own in the present age. They come to life by using the lives of those who die, those who die through illness but still have life forces in them. They can only use past life. They are therefore spirit gates that use the life that remains of people, that soak up, so to speak, what still rises from the remaining life in churchyards and the like.
It is precisely when one penetrates into such worlds that one gets an idea of how infinitely populated the world behind the human sensory world is, and how diverse the classes of such spiritual beings are, and how these spiritual beings are definitely related to our abilities. For the clever man who is pursued in his activity, if he is not clairvoyant but merely clever, can hold on to his clever thoughts precisely because he is pursued by this troop of spiritual fools. They cling to his thoughts, tug them and give them weight so that they stay with him, whereas otherwise he would quickly have the thoughts disappear.
These entities are therefore extremely strongly mocked by the gnome-like entities. The gnome-like entities do not want to tolerate them in their realm, but they belong to the same realm. They are constantly driving them away, and it is a tough battle between the gnome people and this people of spiritual fools, who actually make wisdom possible for man in the first place, for otherwise wisdom would be fleeting, would vanish the moment it arises, could not remain. As I said, they are difficult to discover, these entities, because it is very easy to roll down into the Ahrimanic when you ask the relevant question. But you can find them on such occasions as I have indicated, by following particularly clever people who have a whole troop of such entities behind them. Moreover, if there are not enough clever thoughts clinging to man, these entities can be found on all kinds of monuments of wisdom. For example - but they are also difficult to find there - they stay in libraries when there is something clever in the books. If there is something stupid in the books, then these beings are not to be found, they are only to be found where there is something clever; they cling to that.
We gain insight, so to speak, into a realm that surrounds us, that exists like the realms of nature, and which has something to do with our own abilities, but which is also difficult for us to judge. Therefore, if you want to judge it, you have to rely on these gnome-like beings and give something to their statements, and they find them extraordinarily stupid and impudent. But these beings have another characteristic. If they are pursued too much by the gnome-like spirits of nature, then they take refuge in human heads, and while they are actually almost giants outside in nature - they are extremely large - they become very small when they are in human heads. One could say that they are a kind of abnormal nature spirits, but they are intimately connected with the whole human development on earth.
Another kind is that which lives preferably in the aqueous and aerial elements, like those entities which you find described by me in the mystery dramas alluded to as the sylph-like entities and so on. These entities that I am now referring to have to do preferably with the world of appearances, of beautiful appearances; they attach themselves less to clever people than to artistic natures. But they are also very difficult to discover because they can easily hide. They are to be found where there are real works of art, where the human form or natural forms or the like are present in appearance. That is where they can be found. As I said, we can only discover these entities with difficulty. For if we ask ourselves: How is it that we are interested in beautiful appearances, that under certain circumstances we take greater pleasure in a beautiful statue than in a living human being - a pleasure of a different kind, to be sure, but a greater pleasure - or that we are edified and delighted by the melodic or harmonic arrangement of sounds? - then we very easily collapse into another realm, the realm of the Luciferic beings. But it is not only the luciferic entities that carry the artistic, but again such a realm of elementary entities, which keep man, who would otherwise always be inclined to have no interest in the artistically beautiful appearance because it is unreal, awake in this interest, which stimulate the artistic interest at all.
Now it is so difficult to discover these entities because they can hide even more easily than the fools in the spirit world, for they are actually only there where beauty asserts itself. And if you are devoted to beauty, if you enjoy beauty, then you will certainly not see these beings. Why?
In order to become aware of these beings in a normal way, you must actually try, if you are somehow devoted to artistic impressions, to direct your clairvoyant gaze towards those beings that you find described in the same scene as nymph-like or sylph-like beings, which are also present in the elemental realms of nature, and you must put yourself in their place. One must, so to speak, look at the others with these air and water beings, who are there in the enjoyment of beauty. And since that is difficult, one must help oneself in another way. Well, fortunately, I would say, one can easily discover these beings if one listens to someone who speaks quite beautifully and whose language one does not understand properly, where one only hears the sounds without understanding their meaning. If you give yourself over to this beautiful speaking - but it must be beautifully spoken, it must be spoken oratorically, and you do not have to understand it properly - then you can acquire the ability, it is an intimate, delicate ability, to see these beings. So one must, so to speak, try to acquire the talent of the sylphs and to strengthen it through that talent which develops when one listens to speeches which are beautifully spoken and which one does not understand, whereby one also does not listen to what they are supposed to mean, but only to the beautiful speaking. Then one discovers these entities, which are everywhere where the beautiful is, and give their support so that man can have the right interest in the beautiful.
And then follows the great disappointment, then follows the great terrible astonishment. These beings are in fact the ugliest things one can discover, horrible beings, the archetypes of ugliness. And once one has acquired the spiritual eye for these beings and then visits some studio with this spiritual eye where artistic creations are made, one finds that it is these beings, like spiders, that are actually at the bottom of the world's existence on earth, so that man has an interest in beauty. It is these horrible spider beings of an elemental kind that awaken the interest in beauty. Man would not be able to have any real interest in beauty if his soul were not enmeshed in a world of hideous spider creatures.
When one walks through a gallery in this way - for what I have told you is all just to discover the forms of these beings, they are there every time man enjoys beauty - one has no idea how one's interest in the most beautiful images is supported by the fact that these ugliest spiders crawl in and out of all ears and nostrils. At the bottom of ugliness rises man's enthusiasm for beauty. That is a secret of the world. One needs, I would say, the incitement of ugliness in order for beauty to emerge. And the great artistic natures were those who, through their strong corporeality, were able to endure the penetration of these spiders in order to produce a Sistine Madonna or something similar. Whatever beauty is produced in the world is produced in such a way that it stands out from a sea of ugliness through the enthusiasm of the human soul.
You must not believe that when you get behind the veil of the sensual, when you reach the realm beyond the threshold, you will find nothing but beauty. Don't think that anyone who knows these things is being careless when he says that people must be held back at the threshold of the spiritual world if they are not properly prepared. - For first of all one must become acquainted with the thoroughly unedifying background for everything that one has before the curtain as something uplifting and edifying. And if, therefore, you indulge in the elementary world, which belongs to the air and the water, then you will again see the great struggle of the fleeting world of sylphs and the world of undins against these archetypes of ugliness. I say spider-teeth; they do not consist of the spider's web, but are built of the element of water and of the element of water vapor. They are fleetingly formed aerial figures, which increase their ugliness still further by having a different ugliness every second, whereby one always has the feeling that every next ugliness, which is superimposed on a previous one, is even greater than the previous one. This is the world that is present in the air and water just as much as that which is pleasant in the air and water.
And so that man can develop enthusiasm for the good, something else takes place. With the other beings one can say that they are more or less there, but with the beings I want to speak of now, one must actually say that they are constantly developing, and they develop precisely when the human being has a certain inner warmth for the good. In this warmth those entities develop which are now of a fiery, warm nature, entities which live in the present, but which actually have such a nature as I have described in my “Secret Science in Outline” for the Saturnian existence of man.
As man was in the old Saturn existence, so are these beings today. Only they are not shaped like man, but they have such a nature. One cannot say of them that they are beautiful or ugly or the like; one must judge them from the point of view given to one by the ordinary elementary warmth beings that are also present. The whole spiritual investigation is extraordinarily difficult, for it is extraordinarily difficult to get close to these beings that live only in warmth, that is, in the old sense of the word, in “fire”, and when one does get close to them, it is not pleasant. For example, you can get to it when you are suffering from a severe fever. But as a rule you are not a very objective observer. Otherwise it is a question of developing an appreciation of such warmth beings through the further training of the remedies given in my books. But these warmth beings already have a certain relationship to those beings that appear especially when the human being develops a warm enthusiasm for the good. But the relationship is quite peculiar.
I will hypothetically assume - because this is the only way I can actually describe the matter - that there are such warmth beings of a normal kind, which in general derive from the human physical warmth, which is greater than the warmth of the surroundings. Man has his own warmth. Thus these beings are in his vicinity. And now in a person who is enthusiastic for the good, these other beings, which are also warmth beings, but of a different kind, are brought forth. But when they are near the normal fire beings, they immediately withdraw from them and slip into the innermost part of the human being. If you make a lot of effort to discover the characteristics of these beings from the point of view of the normal warmth beings, you will find that these beings have an intimate but terribly strongly developed sense of shame. They absolutely do not want to be observed by other beings of the spiritual world and flee from them because they are ashamed to be seen, fleeing above all into the innermost parts of people, so that they are difficult to discover. They can actually only be discovered if, let us say, you observe yourself at certain moments which you cannot actually bring about so easily at will. Suppose you are reading something and are moved to tears simply by reading a scene that moves you dramatically, without you being a sentimental person. Some great, good action, for my sake in a novel, is described, you are moved to tears. If you then observe yourself, you can discover how whole crowds of such beings - who have such a finely and intimately developed sense of shame that they do not want to be seen by all other beings of the spiritual world - flee into your heart, into your whole inner chest in general, how they come to you, how they seek protection from the other beings of the elemental-spiritual worlds and especially from the other warmth beings.
There is a significant power of repulsion between the normal warmth beings and these warmth beings, who are endowed with such an extraordinarily strong sense of shame, who only live in the moral sphere of humans and flee from contact with other spiritual beings. These beings are present in much greater numbers than is usually thought, and it is they who endow man with enthusiasm for the morally good. Man would not easily acquire this enthusiasm for the morally good if these entities did not come to his aid. And if man loves the moral, then he is actually in league, in unconscious league with these entities.
Certain characteristics of these entities are such that one can easily misunderstand this whole realm. For indeed, why are these beings ashamed? They are really ashamed for the reason that the whole remaining spiritual world of the elemental kingdom, in which these beings are, actually despises them, does not want to know anything about them. And these beings sense this, and because they are such despised beings, they work precisely towards enthusiasm for the good.
I do not want to touch on certain other characteristics of these beings, because you can already see how peculiarly the human soul is touched when one talks about the hideous spider beings. That is why I would like to leave certain characteristics of these beings untouched. But we have seen how that which develops here in the realm of the sense being as the true, the beautiful, the good, certainly develops out of foundations which these three spiritual realms, which I have described, need, just as we as human beings on earth need the ground on which we walk. Not as if these entities produce the true, the beautiful and the good, they do not. But the thoughts that express the true, that signify the true, need the spiritual fools so that they can move on their shoulders. And the beautiful that man produces needs the ugly water and air spiders so that it can rise out of this sea of ugliness. And the good needs a realm of beings that cannot show itself at all among the other decent warm beings, that must always shy away, and that precisely because of this evokes enthusiasm for the impulses of the good.
If it were not for all these beings, we would have to have, if not exactly leaden soldiers, at least heavy vapors in our heads instead of our thoughts. Not very clever things would come out of it. And in order to produce beauty, we would have to have the gift of bringing this beauty to life a little, so that people would be interested in it and so on. Three such elementary realms are necessary so that what we need for our thought activity, for our emotional activity in the beautiful, for our will activity in the good, is present here in the realm of the sense world.
If we look at the normal elementary kingdoms, that is, if we use the popular expression - the kingdoms of the gnomes, sylphs, undines, salamanders, we actually have kingdoms in them that still want to become something in the world. They are approaching similar forms that we have in our sensory world, only they will be different, but they will one day become perceptible to such senses as people have today, whereas today they are not perceptible to the ordinary senses in their elementary existence.
But the entities which I have now described to you have already snapped over the level which humans and animals or plants have today, are further than these, have already snapped over. So that if, for example, we could go back to the old lunar being that preceded earthly existence, we would find there those beings that we find here today as those shamefully morally inspiring beings on earth. We would see them on the old moon as a real 'animal world, which would also be visible to earthly eyes, spinning around like this, from tree to tree, we say. But you must recall the moon's existence as I have described it in my “Secret Science”. This lunar existence is of course a soft and fleeting one, and things metamorphose, transform themselves. And between these entities, those ugly beings that I have described, those primordial spiders, with which the old moon was completely interspersed and which were visible there, then spin around. And then there were also those beings who today accompany the wise man as the fools. They were there, and they caused the old moon to dissolve, so that the earth could emerge from it. Even here, during our earthly existence, these beings take no pleasure in the formation of crystals, but in all the chopping up of the mineral.
So while we can say of the other, normal elemental beings that they will one day become visible, perceptible to the senses, we must say of these beings that they were once perceptible to the senses and have now, however, snapped over into the spiritual through ahrimanic and luciferic spirituality. So that we have two kinds of elemental beings, an ascending and a descending kind. And I would like to say: our world of beauty grows on the mold of the old lunar ugliness - for it was abundant during the old lunar existence.
You have an analogy in nature when you take the manure, the fertilizer, out into the fields and then the most beautiful plants blossom from it. There you have the analogy of nature, only that the manure, the dung, also confronts you sensually. So it is when you look spiritually at that which is only half real as the world of beauty. That which is only half real as a world of beauty, let it stand before you without taking into consideration what else is teeming alive in the three kingdoms of nature on earth, let, for my sake, all that which sprouts forth from the earth in beautiful after-effects appear before your spirit. In any case, just as the most beautiful flowers sprout forth in a meadow, so you must mentally imagine among them that mould, that fertilizer, the moon fertilizer, which contains those ugly spiders I have described. Just as your cabbage will not grow without your mucking out, neither can beauty blossom on the earth without the gods fertilizing the earth with ugliness. This is the inner necessity of life, and this inner necessity of life must be known, for it alone gives us the ability to face what actually surrounds us in nature with knowledge.
Whoever believes that beauty can be brought forth in art on earth without the basis of this ugliness is like a person who says: But it is actually horrible that people fertilize, they should rather let the beautiful things grow without manure. - It is simply not possible for beauty to be produced without the basis of ugliness. And if you don't want to indulge in illusions about the world, that is, if you want to truly recognize the real and not the illusory, then you have to recognize these things. That is necessary. Anyone who believes that there is art in the world without ugliness does not know art either. Why not? Well, simply because only those who have an idea of what I have described to you today will be able to enjoy works of art in the right way, because they know what they are bought for in the world. And anyone who wants to enjoy works of art without this awareness is actually like a person who wants to stop fertilizing the fields. He then does not know what grows in nature, but in reality has only the illusion before him, plants made of papier-mâché, so to speak. Even if he has real plants, he only has plants made of papier-mâché! He who does not feel the ugliness in his undergrounds does not have the right delight in beauty.
This is the way the world is set up. And that is what mankind must learn if it does not want to continue wandering through the world - as I have said before - like earthworms, which also cling to their element and do not look up to what is real. But people can only develop their inherent talents if they confront reality. Reality, however, is not given by merely talking about spirit, spirit, spirit, but by really getting to know the spiritual world. But then one must also expose oneself to the fact that under certain circumstances something like what I have described to you today may come to light in certain areas of the spiritual world.