The Evolution of the Earth and Man
and the Influence of the Stars
GA 354
31 July 1924, Dornach
Lecture VI
Rudolf Steiner: Good morning, gentlemen! Has someone thought of a question during the last weeks?
Question: Sir, I would like to ask about various foods—beans and carrots, for instance: what effect they have on the body. You have already spoken about potatoes; perhaps we could hear something about other foodstuffs. Some vegetarians won't eat things that have hung in the air, like beans or peas. And when one looks at a field of grain, one wonders how the various grains differ—for apparently all the peoples of the earth cultivate some grain or other.
Dr. Steiner: So—the question is about the relation of various foods to the human body. Well, first of all we should gain a clear idea of nutrition itself. One's immediate thought of nutrition is that when we eat something, it goes through the mouth down into the stomach, then it is deposited farther in the body and finally we get rid of it; then we must eat again, and so on. But the process is not as simple as that. It is much more complicated. And if one wants to understand how the human being is really related to various foods, one must first be clear about the kinds of food one definitely needs.
Now the very first thing one needs, the substance one must have without fail, is protein. Let us write all this on the board, so that we have it complete. So, protein, as it is in a hen's egg, for instance—but not just in eggs; protein is in all foods. One needs protein without fail. The second thing one needs is fats. These too are in all foods. Fats are even in plants. The third thing has a name that will be less familiar to you, but one needs to know it: carbohydrates. Carbohydrates are found particularly in potatoes, but they are also found in large quantity in all other plants. The important fact about carbohydrates is that when we eat them, they are slowly turned into starch by the saliva in our mouth and the secretions in our stomach. Starch is something we need without fail, but we don't eat starch; we eat foods that contain carbohydrates, and the carbohydrates are turned into starch inside us. Then they are converted once again, in the further process of digestion, into sugar. And we need sugar. So you see, we get the sugar we need from the carbohydrates. But we still need something else: minerals. We get them partly by adding them to our food, for example in the form of salt, and partly they are already contained in all our foodstuffs.
Now when we consider protein, we must realize how greatly it differs in animals and human beings from what it is in plants. Plants contain protein too, but they don't eat it, so where do they get it from? They get it out of the ground and out of the air, from the mineral world; they can take their protein from lifeless, mineral sources. Neither animal nor man can do that. A human being cannot use the protein that is to be got from lifeless elements—he would then only be a plant—he must get his protein as it is already prepared in plants or animals.
Actually, to be able to live on this earth the human being needs the plants. But now this is the amazing fact: the plants could not live on the earth either if human beings were not here! So, gentlemen, we reach the interesting fact—and we must grasp it quite clearly: that of all things the two most essential for human life are the green sap in the green leaves and blood. The green in the sap of a plant is called chlorophyll. Chlorophyll is contained in the green leaf. And the one other essential thing is blood.
Now this brings us to something very remarkable.
Think how you breathe: that is also a way of taking in nourishment. You take oxygen in from the air; you breathe it in. But there is carbon spread through your entire body. If you go down into the earth where there are coal deposits, you've got black coal. When you sharpen a pencil, you've got graphite. Coal and graphite: they're both carbon. Your whole body is made of carbon (as well as other substances). Carbon is formed in the human body. You could say, a man is just a heap of black coal! But you could also say something else. Because—remember the most expensive thing in the world? a diamond—and that's made of carbon; it just has a different form. And so, if you like the sound of it better, you could say you're made of glittering diamonds. The black carbon, that graphite in the pencil, and the diamonds: they are all the same substance. If someday the coal that is dug out of the earth can by some process be made transparent, you'll have diamonds. So we have diamonds hidden in our body. Or we are a coal field! But now when oxygen combines with carbon in the blood, you have carbon dioxide. And you know carbon dioxide quite well: you only have to think of Seltzer water with the bubbles in it: they are the carbon dioxide. It is a gas. So one can have this picture: A human being inhales oxygen from the air, the oxygen spreads all through his blood; in his blood he has carbon, and he exhales carbon dioxide. You breathe oxygen in, you breathe carbon dioxide out.
In the course of the earth's evolution, gentlemen, which I have recently been describing to you, everything would long ago have been poisoned by the carbon dioxide coming from the human beings and animals. For this evolution has been going on for a long time. As you can see, since long, long ago there could have been no human kingdom or animal kingdom alive on the earth unless plants had had a very different character from those kingdoms. Plants do not take in oxygen: they take in the carbon dioxide that human beings and animals exhale. Plants are just as greedy for the carbon dioxide as human beings are for oxygen.
Now if we look at a plant [see drawing]—root, stem, leaves, blossoms: the plant absorbs carbon dioxide in every part of it. And now the carbon in the carbon dioxide is deposited in the plant, and the oxygen is breathed out by the plant. Human beings and animals get it back again. Man gives carbon dioxide out and kills everything; the plant keeps back the carbon, releases the oxygen and brings everything to life again. And the plant could do nothing with the carbon dioxide if it did not have its green sap, the chlorophyll. This green sap of the plant, gentlemen, is a magician. It holds the carbon back inside the plant and lets the oxygen go free. Our blood combines oxygen with carbon; the green plant-sap separates the carbon again from the carbon dioxide and sets the oxygen free. Think what an excellent arrangement nature has made, that plants and animals and human beings should complement one another in this way! They complement one another perfectly.
But we must go on. The human being not only needs the oxygen that the plant gives him, but he needs the entire plant. With the exception of poisonous plants and certain plants which contain very little of these substances, the human being needs all plants not only for his breathing but also for food. And that brings us to another remarkable connection. A plant consists of root, if it is an annual plant (we won't consider the trees at this moment)—of root, leaf and stem, blossom and fruit. Now look at the root for a moment. It is in the earth. It contains many minerals, because minerals are in the earth and the root clings to the earth with its tiny fine rootlets, so it is constantly absorbing those minerals. So the root of the plant has a special relation to the mineral realm of the earth.
And now look here, gentlemen! The part of the human being that is related to the whole earth is the head. Not the feet, but actually the head. When the human being starts to be an earth-man in the womb, he has at first almost nothing but a head. He begins with his head. His head takes the shape of the whole cosmos and the shape of the earth. And the head particularly needs minerals. For it is from the head that the forces go out that fill the human body with bones, for instance. Everything that makes a human being solid is the result of the way the head has been formed. While the head itself is still soft, as in the womb, it cannot form bones properly. But as it becomes harder and harder itself, it gives over to the body the forces by which both man and animal are able to form their solid parts, particularly their bones. You can see from this that we need roots. They are related to the earth and contain minerals. We need the minerals for bone-building. Bones consist of calcium carbonate, calcium phosphate; those are minerals. So you can see that the human being needs roots in order to strengthen his head.
And so, gentlemen, if—for instances—a child is becoming weak in his head—inattentive, hyperactive—he will usually have a corresponding symptom: worms in his intestines. Worms develop easily in the intestines if the head forces are too weak, because the head does not then work down strongly enough into the rest of the body. Worms find no lodging in a human body if the head forces are working down strongly into the intestines. You can see how magnificently the human body is arranged!—everything is related. And if one's child has worms, one should realize the child has become weak in his head. Also—whoever wants to be a teacher has to know these things—if there are persons who at a later age are weak-minded, one can be sure they have had worms when they were young.
And so what must one do if one observes this in the child? The simplest remedy is to give him carrots to eat for a while—with his other food, of course; naturally, one couldn't just feed him on carrots alone. Carrots are the root of the plant. They grow down in the earth and have a large quantity of minerals. They have the forces of the earth in them, and when they are taken into the stomach, they are able to work up through the blood into the head. Only substances rich in minerals are able to reach the head. Substances rich in minerals, root substances, give strength to a human being by way of the head. That is extraordinarily important. It is through carrots that the uppermost parts of the head become strong—which is precisely what the human being needs in order to be inwardly firm and vigorous, not soft.
If you look at the carrot plant, you can't help seeing that its strength has gone particularly into the root. It is almost entirely root. The only part of the plant one is interested in is the root. The rest of it, the green part, is of no importance, it just sits there up above. So the carrot is particularly good as a food substance to maintain the human head. And if sometimes you yourselves feel empty-headed, dull, can't think properly, then it's fine if you too will eat carrots for a while! Naturally, they will help children the most.
But now if we compare a potato to a carrot—well, first of all it looks quite different. Of course, the potato plant has a green part. And then it has the part we eat, what we call the tubers, deep down in the earth. Now if we would think superficially, we could say those tubers are the roots. But that is not correct; the tubers are not roots. If you look carefully down into the soil, you can see the real roots hanging on the tubers. The real roots are tiny rootlets, root hairs, that hang on the tubers. They fall away easily. When you gather up the potatoes, the hairs have already fallen away. Only in the first moment when you are lifting a potato loose from the soil, the hairs are still all over it. When we eat a potato, we are really eating a piece of swollen, enlarged stem. It only appears to be a root; in reality it is stem. The leaves are metamorphosed. The potato is something down there between the root and the stem. Therefore it does not have as much mineral content as the carrot; it is not as earthy. It grows in the earth, but it is not so strongly related to the earth. And it contains particularly carbohydrates; not so many minerals, but carbohydrates.
So now, gentlemen, you can say to yourselves: When I eat carrots, my body can really take it easy, for all it needs is saliva to soften the carrot. All it needs is saliva and stomach secretions, pepsin and so forth for all the important substance of the carrot to reach the head. We need minerals, and minerals are furnished by any kind of root, but in greatest amounts by such a root as the carrot.
But now, when we eat potatoes, first they go into the mouth and stomach. There the body has to exert strength to derive starch from them. Then the digestive process goes further in the intestines. In order that something can go into the blood and also reach the head, there must be more exertion still, because sugar has to be derived from the starch. Only then can it go to the head. So one has to use still greater forces. Now think of this, gentlemen: when I exert my strength upon some external thing, I become weak. This is really a secret of human physiology: that if I chop wood, if I use my external bodily strength, I become weak; but if I exert an inner strength, transforming carbohydrates into starch and starch into sugar, I become strong. Precisely through the fact that I permeate myself with sugar by eating potatoes, I become strong. When I use my strength externally, I become weak; if I use it internally, I become strong. So it is not a matter of simply filling oneself up with food, but of the food generating strength in our body.
And so one can say: food from roots—and all roots have the same effect as carrots although not to the same degree: they all work particularly on the head—so, food from roots gives the body what it needs for itself. Foods that lean toward the green of the plant and contain carbohydrates provide the body with strength it needs for work, for movement.
I have already spoken about the potato. While it requires a terribly large expenditure of strength, it leaves a man weak afterwards, and does not provide him with any continuing strength. But the principle I have just given you holds good even for the potato.
Now to the same extent that the potato is a rather poor foodstuff, all the grains—wheat, rye, and so on—are good foodstuffs. The grains also contain carbohydrates, and of such a nature that the human being forms starch and sugar in the healthiest possible way. Actually, the carbohydrates of the grains can make him stronger than he can make himself by any other means. Only think for a moment how strong people are who live on farms, simply through the fact that they eat large quantities of their own homemade bread which contains the grain from their fields! They only need to have healthy bodies to start with, then if they can digest the rather coarse bread, it is really the healthiest food for them. They must first have healthy bodies, but then they become quite especially strong through the process of making starch and sugar.
Now a question might be raised. You see, human beings have come in the course of their evolution—shall I say, quite of their own accord—to eating the grains differently from the way animals eat them. A horse eats his oats almost as they grow. Animals eat their kernels of grain raw, just as they come from the plant. The birds would have a hard time getting their seed if they had to depend upon someone cooking it for them first! But human beings have come of themselves to cooking the grains. And now, gentlemen, what happens when we cook the grain? Well, when we cook the grain, we don't eat it cold, we eat it warm. And it's a fact, that to digest our food we need inner warmth. Unless there is warmth we can't transform our carbohydrates into starch and the starch into sugar: that requires inner heat.
So if we first apply external heat to the foodstuffs, we help the body: it does not have to provide all the warmth itself. By being cooked first, the foods have already begun the fire process, the warmth process. That's the first result. The second is, that they have been entirely changed. Think what happens to the grain when I make flour into bread. It becomes something quite different. And how has it become different? Well, first I have ground the seeds. What does that mean? I have crushed them into tiny, tiny pieces. And you see, what I do there with the seeds, grinding them, making them fine, I'd otherwise have to do later within my own body! Everything I do externally, I'd otherwise have to do internally, inside my body; so by doing those things, I relieve my body. And the same with the baking itself: all the things I do in cooking, I save my body from doing. I bring the foods to a condition in which my body can more easily digest them.
You have only to think of the difference if someone would eat raw potatoes instead of cooked ones. If someone were to eat his potatoes raw, his stomach would have to provide a tremendous amount of warmth to transform those raw potatoes—which are almost starch already. And the extent to which it could transform them would not be sufficient. So then the potatoes would reach the intestines and the intestines would also have to use a great amount of energy. Then the potatoes would just stay put in the intestines, for the subsequent forces would not be able to carry them farther into the body. So if one eats raw potatoes, either one just loads one's stomach with them and the intestines can't even get started on them, or one fills up the intestines; in either case there is no further digestion. But if the potatoes undergo a preparatory stage through cooking or some other means, then the stomach does not have so much to do, or the intestines either, and the potatoes go over properly into the blood and right up into the head. So you see, by cooking our foods, especially those that are counted among the carbohydrates, we are able to help our nutrition.
You are certainly acquainted with all the new kinds of foolishness in connection with nutrition—for instance, the raw food faddists, who are not going to cook anything anymore, they're going to eat everything raw. How does this come about? It's because people no longer know what's what from a materialistic science, and they shy away from a spiritual science, so they think a few things out on their own. The whole raw food fad is a fantasy. For a time someone living on raw food can whip the body along—in this situation the body has to be using very strong forces, so it has to be whipped—but then it will collapse all the more completely.
But now, gentlemen, let us come to the fats. Plants, almost all of them, contain fats which they derive from the minerals. Now fats do not enter the human body so easily as carbohydrates and minerals. Minerals are not even changed. For example, when you shake salt into your soup, that salt goes almost unchanged up into your head. You get it as salt in your head. But when you eat potatoes, you don't get potatoes in your head, you get sugar. The conversion takes place as I described to you. With the fats, however, whether they're plant fats or animal fats, it's not such a simple matter. When fats are eaten, they are almost entirely eaten up by the saliva, by the gastric secretions, by the intestinal secretions, and they become something quite different that then goes over into the blood. The animal and the human being must form their own fats in their intestines and in their blood, with forces which the fats they eat call forth.
You see, that is the difference between fats and sugar or minerals. The human being still takes his salt and his sugar from nature. He has to derive the sugar from the potato and the rye and so on, but there is still something of nature in it. But with the fats that man or animal have in them, there is nothing anymore of nature. They have formed them themselves. The human being would have no strength if he did not eat; his intestines and blood need fats. So we can say: Man himself cannot form minerals. If he did not take in minerals, his body would never be able to build them by itself. If he did not take in carbohydrates, if he did not eat bread or something similar from which he gets carbohydrates, he would never be able to form sugar by himself. And if he could not form sugar, he would be a weakling forever. So be grateful for the sugar, gentlemen! Because you are chock-full of sweetness, you have strength. The moment you would no longer be full to the brim with your own sweetness, you would have no strength, you would collapse.
And you know, that holds good even in connection with the various peoples. There are certain peoples who consume very little sugar or foodstuffs that produce sugar. These peoples have weak physical forces. Then there are certain peoples who eat many carbohydrates that form sugar, and they are strong.
But the human being doesn't have it so easy with the fats. If someone has fats in him (and this is true also of the animals), that is his own accomplishment, the accomplishment of his body. Fats are entirely his own production. The human being destroys whatever fats he takes in, plant fats or animal fats, and through their destruction he develops strength. With potatoes, rye, wheat, he develops strength by converting the substances. With the fats that he eats, he develops strength by destroying the substances.
If I destroy something outside of myself, I become tired and exhausted. And if I have had a big fat beefsteak and destroy that inside myself, I become weak in the same way; but my destruction of the fat beefsteak or of the plant fat gives me strength again, so that I can produce my own fat if my body is predisposed to it. So you see, the consumption of fat works very differently in the human body from the consumption of carbohydrates. The human body, gentlemen, is exceedingly complicated, and what I have been describing to you is tremendous work. Much must take place in the human body for it to be able to destroy those plant fats.
But now let us think how it is when someone eats green stuff, the stems and leaves of a plant. When he eats green stuff, he is getting fats from the plants. Why is it that sometimes a stem is so hard? Because it then gives its forces to leaves that are going to be rich in carbohydrates. And if the leaves stay green—the greener they are, the more fats they have in them. So when someone eats bread, for instance, he can't take in many fats from the bread. He takes in more, for example, from watercress—that tiny plant with the very tiny leaves—more fats than when he eats bread. That's how the custom came about of putting butter on our bread, some kind of fat. It wasn't just for the taste. And why country people want bacon with their bread. There again is fat, and that also is eaten for two reasons.
When I eat bread, the bread works upon my head because the root elements of a plant work up into the stem. The stem, even though it is stem and grows above the ground in the air, still has root forces in it. The question is not whether something is above in the air, but whether it has any root forces. Now the leaf, the green leaf, does not have root forces. No green leaf ever appears down in the earth. In late summer and autumn, when the sun forces are no longer working so strongly, the stem can mature. But the leaf needs the strongest sun forces for it to unfold; it grows toward the sun. So we can say, the green part of the plant works particularly on heart and lungs, while the root strengthens the head. The potato also is able to work into the head. When we eat greens, they give us particularly plant fats; they strengthen our heart and lungs, the middle man, the chest man.
That, I would say, is the secret of human nutrition: that if I want to work upon my head, I have roots or stems for dinner. If I want to work upon my heart or my lungs, I make myself a green salad. And in this case, because these substances are destroyed in the intestines and only their forces proceed to work, cooking is not so necessary. That's why leaves can be eaten raw as salad. Whatever is to work on the head cannot be eaten raw; it must be cooked. Cooked foods work particularly on the head. Lettuce and similar things work particularly on heart and lungs, building them up, nourishing them through the fats.
But now, gentlemen, the human being must not only nurture the head and the middle body, the breast region, but he must nurture the digestive organs themselves. He needs a stomach, intestines, kidneys, and a liver, and he must build up these digestive organs himself. Now the interesting fact is this: to build up his digestive organs he needs protein for food, the protein that is in plants, particularly as contained in their blossoms, and most particularly in their fruit. So we can say: the root nourishes the head particularly [see drawing earlier]; the middle of the plant, stem and leaves, nourishes the chest particularly; and fruit nourishes the lower body.
When we look out at our grain fields we can say, Good that they are there! for that nourishes our head. When we look down at the lettuce we've planted, all those leaves that we eat without cooking because they are easily digested in the intestines—and it's their forces that we want—there we get everything that maintains our chest organs. But cast an eye up at the plums and apples, at the fruits growing on the trees—ah! those we don't have to bother to cook much, for they've been cooked by the sun itself during the whole summer! There an inner ripening has already been happening, so that they are something quite different from the roots, or from stalks and stems (which are not ripened but actually dried up by the sun). The fruits, as I said, we don't have to cook much—unless we have a weak organism, in which case the intestines cannot destroy the fruits. Then we must cook them; we must have stewed fruit and the like. If someone has intestinal illnesses, he must be careful to take his fruit in some cooked form—sauce, jam, and so forth. If one has a perfectly healthy digestive system, a perfectly healthy intestinal system, then fruits are the right thing to nourish the lower body, through the protein they contain. Protein from any of the fruits nourishes your stomach for you, nourishes all your digestive organs in your lower body.
You can see what a good instinct human beings have had for these things! Naturally, they have not known in concepts all that I've been telling you, but they have known it instinctively. They have always prepared a mixed diet of roots, greens and fruit; they have eaten all of them, and even the comparative amounts that one should have of these three different foods have been properly determined by their instinct.
But now, as you know, people not only eat plants, they eat animals too, the flesh of animals, animal fat and so on.
Certainly it is not for anthroposophy ever to assume a fanatical or a sectarian attitude. Its task is only to tell how things are. One simply cannot say that people should eat only plants, or that they should also eat animals, and so on. One can only say that some people with the forces they have from heredity are simply not strong enough to perform within their bodies all the work necessary to destroy plant fats, to destroy them so completely that then forces will develop in their bodies for producing their own fat. You see, a person who eats only plant fats—well, either he's renounced the idea of becoming an imposing, portly fellow, or else he must have an awfully good digestive system, so healthy that it is easy for him to destroy the plant fats and in this way get forces to build his own fat. Most people are really unable to produce their own fat if they have only plant fats to destroy. When one eats animal fat in meat, that is not entirely destroyed. Plant fats don't go out beyond the intestines, they are destroyed in the intestines. But the fat contained in meat does go beyond, it goes over into the human being. And the person may be weaker than if he were on a diet of just plant fats.
Therefore, we must distinguish between two kinds of bodies. First there are the bodies that do not like fat, they don't enjoy eating bacon, they just don't like to eat fatty foods. Those are bodies that destroy plant fats comparatively easily and want in that way to form their own fat. They say: “Whatever fat I carry around, I want to make myself; I want my very own fat.” But if someone heaps his table with fatty foods, then he's not saying, “I want to make my own fat”; he's saying, “The world has to give me my fat.” For animal fat goes over into the body, making the work of nutrition easier.
When a child sucks a candy, he's not doing that for nourishment. There is, to be sure, something nutritious in it, but the child doesn't suck it for that; he sucks it for the sweet taste. The sweetness is the object of his consciousness. But if an adult eats beef fat, or pork fat, or the like, well, that goes over into his body. It satisfies his craving just as the candy satisfies the child's craving. But it is not quite the same, for the adult feels this craving inside him. The adult needs this inner craving in order to respond to his inner being. That is why he loves meat. He eats it because his body loves it.
But it is no use being fanatic about these things. There are people who simply cannot live if they don't have meat. A person must consider carefully whether he really will be able to get on without it. If he does decide he can do without it and changes over from a meat to a vegetarian diet, he will feel stronger than he was before. That's sometimes a difficulty, obviously: some people can't bear the thought of living without meat. If, however, one does become a vegetarian, he feels stronger—because he is no longer obliged to deposit alien fat in his body; he makes his own fat, and this makes him feel stronger.
I know this from my own experience. I could not otherwise have endured the strenuous exertion of these last twenty-four years! I never could have traveled entire nights, for instance, and then given a lecture the next morning. For it is a fact, that if one is a vegetarian one carries out a certain activity within one that is spared the non-vegetarian, who has it done first by an animal. That's the important difference.
But now don't get the idea that I would ever agitate for vegetarianism! It must always be first established whether a person is able to become a vegetarian or not; it is an individual matter.
You see, this is especially important in connection with protein. One can digest protein if one is able to eat plant protein and break it down in the intestines. And then one gets the forces from it. But the moment the intestines are weak, one must get the protein externally, which means one must eat the right kind of protein, which will be animal protein. Hens that lay eggs are also animals! So protein is something that is really judged quite falsely unless it is considered from an anthroposophical point of view.
When I eat roots, their minerals go up into my head. When I eat salad greens, their forces go to my chest, lungs, and heart—not their fats, but the forces from their fats. When I eat fruit, the protein from the fruit stays in the intestines. And the protein from animal substances goes beyond the intestines into the body; animal protein spreads out. One might think, therefore, that if a person eats plenty of protein, he will be a well-nourished individual. This has led to the fact in this materialistic age that people who had studied medicine were recommending excessive amounts of protein for the average diet: they maintained that one hundred and twenty to one hundred and fifty grams of protein were necessary-which was ridiculous. Today it is known that only a quarter of that amount is necessary. And actually, if a person does eat such enormous and unnecessary amounts of protein—well, then something happens as it once did with a certain professor and his assistant.
They had a man suffering from malnutrition and they wanted to build him up with protein. Now it is generally recognized that when someone is consuming large amounts of protein—it is, of course, converted in him—his urine will show that he has had it in his diet. So now it happened with these two that the man's urine showed no sign of the protein being present in his body. It didn't occur to them that it had already passed through the intestines. The professor was in a terrible state. And the assistant was shaking in his boots as he said timidly: “Sir – Professor—perhaps—through the intestines?” Of course!
What had happened? They had stuffed the man with protein and it was of no use to him, for it had gone from the stomach into the intestines and then out behind. It had not spread into the body at all. If one gulps down too much protein, it doesn't go over into the body at all, but into the fecal waste matter. Even so, the body does get something from it: before it passes out, it lies there in the intestines and becomes poisonous and poisons the whole body. That's what can happen from too much protein. And from this poisoning comes then very frequently arteriosclerosis-so that many people get arteriosclerosis too early, simply from stuffing themselves with too much protein.
It is important, as I have tried to show you, to know these things about nutrition. For most people are thoroughly convinced that the more they eat, the better they are nourished. Of course it is not true. One is often much better nourished if one eats less, because then one does not poison oneself.
The point is really that one must know how the various substances work. One must know that minerals work particularly on the head; carbohydrates—just as they are to be found in our most common foods, bread and potatoes, for instance—work more on the lung system and throat system (lungs, throat, palate and so on). Fats work particularly on heart and blood vessels, arteries and veins, and protein particularly on the abdominal organs. The head has no special amount of protein. What protein it does have—naturally, it also has to be nourished with protein, for after all, it consists of living substances—that protein man has to form himself. And if one overeats, it's no use believing that in that way one is getting a healthy brain, for just the opposite is happening: one is getting a poisoned brain.
Protein: abdominal organs
Fats: heart and blood vessels
Carbohydrates: lungs, throat, palate
Minerals: head
Perhaps we should devote another session to nutrition? That would be good, because these questions are very important. So then, Saturday at nine o'clock.
Sechster Vortrag
Guten Morgen! Nun, meine Herren, hat sich jemand während der langen Zeit eine Frage zurechtgelegt?
Herr Burle: Ich möchte Herrn Doktor einmal fragen über die Nahrungsmittel — über Bohnen, Gelbe Rüben und so weiter, was die für einen Einfluß auf den Körper haben? Über Kartoffeln hat Herr Doktor ja schon gesprochen. Vielleicht können wir über andere Nahrungsmittel noch etwas hören. Manche Vegetarier essen nicht hängende Sachen, wie Bohnen, Erbsen. Wenn man zum Beispiel ein Kornfeld sieht, so gibt das einem auch wieder verschiedene Gedanken über die Brotfrucht, die sehr wahrscheinlich alle Völker der Erde, mit Variationen, haben.
Dr. Steiner: Also es wird gewünscht, daß jetzt etwas gesprochen werden soll über das Verhältnis der Nahrungsmittel zum Menschen. Nun, da ist es notwendig, daß man sich zunächst klarmacht, worauf eigentlich das Ernähren beruht. Man stellt sich zunächst vor, daß die Ernährung darauf beruht, daß der Mensch seine Nahrungsmittel aufnimmt, durch den Mund in den Magen bringt, daß sie sich dann weiter im Körper ablagern, daß er sie wiederum von sich gibt und sich wieder neu ernähren muß und so weiter. So einfach ist aber die Sache nicht, sondern die Dinge sind viel komplizierter. Und man muß, wenn man verstehen will, in welcher Weise eigentlich der Mensch zu den Nahrungsmitteln steht, sich ja erst einmal klarmachen, welcher Art die Nahrungsmittel sind, die der Mensch unbedingt braucht.
Sehen Sie, das erste, was der Mensch braucht, was er unbedingt in sich aufnehmen muß, das ist Eiweiß. Eiweiß also braucht der Mensch unbedingt. Wollen wir uns das einmal aufschreiben, damit wir die Sachen zusammen haben. Also Eiweiß, wie es im Hühnerei zum Beispiel ist; aber nicht nur im Hühnerei, sondern in allen Nahrungsmitteln ist Eiweiß. Eiweiß braucht der Mensch unbedingt. Das zweite, was der Mensch braucht, das sind Fette. Wiederum sind die Fette in allen Nahrungsmitteln drinnen. Es sind auch Fette in den Pflanzen. Das dritte hat einen Namen, der Ihnen weniger geläufig sein wird, den man aber notwendigerweise wissen sollte: Kohlehydrate. Kohlehydrate sind solche Stoffe, wie sie am allermeisten in der Kartoffel zum Beispiel enthalten sind; aber auch in allen anderen Pflanzen sind viel Kohlehydrate. Kohlehydrate sind dadurch ausgezeichnet, daß sie sich, wenn man sie ißt, durch den Speichel des Mundes und durch den Magensaft so langsam in Stärke verwandeln. Die Stärke ist etwas, was der Mensch durchaus braucht; aber er ißt nicht Stärke, sondern er ißt solche Nahrungsmittel, welche Kohlehydrate enthalten; die verwandeln sich in ihm selber in Stärke. Und dann verwandeln sie sich noch einmal bei der weiteren Verdauung in Zucker. Und den Zucker braucht der Mensch. Also in den Kohlehydraten hat er den Zuckergehalt bei sich.
Aber etwas ist noch notwendig für den Menschen: das sind die Salze, die er aufnimmt. Er nimmt sie zum Teil als Zusatz zu den Speisen auf, zum Teil aber sind Salze in allen Speisen schon enthalten.
Wenn wir das Eiweiß betrachten, dann müssen wir bei Tier und Mensch den großen Unterschied ins Auge fassen gegenüber den Pflanzen. Die Pflanzen enthalten auch Eiweiß; sie essen aber kein Eiweiß. Wenn die Pflanzen aber trotzdem Eiweiß in sich haben, woher haben sie das? Sie haben es aus dem Boden, der Luft, aus dem Leblosen, aus dem Mineralischen; sie können nämlich aus dem Leblosen, aus dem Mineralischen ihr Eiweiß bereiten. Das kann weder das Tier noch der Mensch. Der Mensch kann nicht aus dem Leblosen Eiweiß bereiten — da würde er nur Pflanze sein können -, sondern er muß Eiweiß in sich aufnehmen, wie es wenigstens die Pflanzen oder die Tiere schon zubereitet haben.
Überhaupt braucht der Mensch zu seinem Leben auf der Erde die Pflanzen. Und die Pflanzen — das ist nun das Interessante -, die könnten nicht gedeihen, wenn nicht wiederum der Mensch da wäre! Und da ist es interessant, meine Herren, das müssen Sie nur ins Auge fassen, daß die zwei allerwichtigsten Dinge für das Leben sind: der grüne Pflanzensaft in den grünen Blättern und das Blut auf der anderen Seite. Dieses Grün im Pflanzensaft nennt man Chlorophyll, Blattgrün; also das Chlorophyll ist im grünen Blatt enthalten. Und außerdem ist wichtig das Blut. Nun, da ist etwas höchst Eigentümliches: Sehen Sie, wenn Sie den Menschen betrachten, so atmet der Mensch zunächst — das Atmen ist auch eine Ernährung -, der Mensch nimmt Sauerstoff aus der Luft auf, er atmet Sauerstoff ein. In seinem ganzen Körper, überall, ist aber Kohlenstoff abgelagert. Wenn Sie in die Erde hineingeraten, wo ein Kohlenlager ist, so kommen Sie auf die schwarze Kohle; wenn Sie einen Bleistift spitzen, so kommen Sie auf den Graphit. Kohle und Graphit, das ist Kohlenstoff. Sie bestehen alle, außer anderen Stoffen, den ganzen Körper hindurch aus Kohlenstoff; der wird gebildet im menschlichen Körper.
Nun können Sie sagen: Ja, da ist eigentlich der Mensch ein recht schwarzer Rapuzzel gerade in bezug auf den Kohlenstoff! Aber Sie können ja auch noch etwas anderes sagen: Sehen Sie, der teuerste Körper der Welt, der Diamant, besteht auch aus Kohlenstoff, nur in einer anderen Gestalt! Also wenn Sie das lieber haben wollen, können Sie auch sagen: Sie bestehen in bezug auf den Kohlenstoff aus lauter Diamanten. Der dunkle Kohlenstoff, der Graphit des Bleistiftes und der Diamant sind derselbe Stoff. Wenn die Kohle, die Sie aus der Erde ausgraben, durch irgendeine Kunst durchsichtig gemacht werden kann, dann ist sie Diamant. Also diese Diamanten haben wir überall abgelagert in uns. Wir sind ein richtiges Kohlenlager. Wenn aber der Sauerstoff durch das Blut mit dem Kohlenstoff zusammenkommt, dann bildet sich Kohlensäure. Kohlensäure kennen Sie auch sehr gut: Sie brauchen nur Selterswasser zu nehmen; da sind die Perlen drinnen — diese sind die Kohlensäure, das ist ein Gas. So daß Sie also sich vorstellen können: Der Mensch atmet Sauerstoff durch die Luft ein, der Sauerstoff breitet sich durch das ganze Blut aus, im Blute nimmt er den Kohlenstoff auf, er atmet die Kohlensäure aus. Ein atmen Sie Sauerstoff, aus atmen Sie Kohlensäure.
Meine Herren, es wäre in den Vorgängen, die ich Ihnen geschildert habe in der Entwickelung der Erde, längst alles durch Kohlensäure von Menschen und Tieren vergiftet. Denn die Zeit ist ja lang, seit sich alles auf der Erde entwickelt hat. Wie Sie sehen, könnten längst keine Tiere und Menschen mehr auf der Erde leben, wenn nicht die Pflanzen eine ganz andere Eigenschaft hätten: die Pflanzen, die saugen nicht Sauerstoff ein, sondern gerade Kohlensäure, die der Mensch und das Tier ausatmen. So daß also die Pflanzen ebenso gierig sind auf die Kohlensäure wie der Mensch auf den Sauerstoff.
Und wenn Sie nun da die Pflanze haben (siehe Zeichnung): Wurzel, Stengel, Blätter, Blüte, so saugt also die Pflanze überall Kohlensäure ein; die geht hinein. Und jetzt setzt sich der Kohlenstoff, der da in der Kohlensäure drinnen ist, in der Pflanze nieder, und der Sauerstoff wird wiederum ausgeatmet von den Pflanzen. Da haben ihn die Menschen und die Tiere wieder. Der Mensch gibt Kohlensäure her und tötet alles; die Pflanze behält den Kohlenstoff zurück, gibt den Sauerstoff frei und belebt damit alles. Und nichts könnte die Pflanze machen mit der Kohlensäure, wenn nicht der grüne Pflanzensaft, das Chlorophyll, da wäre. Dieser grüne Pflanzensaft, meine Herren, der ist ein Zauberer, der hält den Kohlenstoff in der Pflanze zurück und gibt den Sauerstoff wieder frei. Das Blut verbindet den Sauerstoff mit dem Kohlenstoff; der grüne Pflanzensaft nimmt den Kohlenstoff wiederum aus der Kohlensäure heraus und gibt den Sauerstoff frei.
Denken Sie, was das für eine feine Sache ist in der Natur, daß die Pflanzen, die Menschen und die Tiere sich auf diese Weise ergänzen! Sie ergänzen sich vollständig.
Nun muß man das Folgende sagen. Sehen Sie, der Mensch braucht aber nicht bloß von der Pflanze dasjenige, was sie ihm gibt durch den Sauerstoff, sondern er braucht die ganze Pflanze; mit Ausnahme der Giftpflanzen und mit Ausnahme solcher Pflanzen, die wenig von diesen Stoffen enthalten, braucht der Mensch alle Pflanzen, indem er sie nicht durch Atmung, sondern durch Ernährung bekommt. Und da ist wiederum ein solcher merkwürdiger Zusammenhang. Sehen Sie, die Pflanze besteht ja aus der Wurzel, wenn es eine einjährige Pflanze ist vom Baum wollen wir jetzt absehen -, aus der Wurzel, aus dem Kraut und aus der Blüte mit Frucht. Nun, schauen wir uns einmal die Wurzel an. Die Wurzel, die ist ja in der Erde drinnen; sie enthält namentlich viele Salze, weil in der Erde die Salze drinnen sind. Und die Wurzel hängt mit ihren feinen Würzelchen an dieser Erde; da zieht sie fortwährend aus der Erde die Salze heraus. So daß die Wurzel eben dasjenige ist, was mit dem Mineralreich der Erde, mit den Salzen in besonderer Verbindung steht.
Nun, sehen Sie, meine Herren, verwandt mit der ganzen Erde ist der menschliche Kopf - nicht die Füße, sondern gerade der Kopf ist mit der Erde verwandt. Wenn der Mensch anfängt Erdenmensch zu sein im Mutterleibe, hat er ja zunächst fast nur den Kopf. Beim Kopf fängt er an. Der Kopf ist dem ganzen Weltenall, aber auch der Erde nachgebildet. Und der Kopf braucht vorzugsweise Salze. Denn vom Kopf gehen die Kräfte aus, die den menschlichen Körper zum Beispiel auch mit Knochen durchsetzen. Alles dasjenige, was den Menschen fest macht, geht von der Kopfbildung aus. Wenn der Kopf selber noch weich ist, wie im Mutterleib, dann kann er nicht ordentlich Knochen bilden. Indem der Kopf selber zuerst immer härter und härter wird, gibt er die Kräfte an den Leib ab, damit der Mensch und die Tiere die festen Dinge, vorzugsweise die Knochen bilden können. Daraus sehen Sie schon, daß man die Wurzel, die mit der Erde verwandt ist und die Salze enthält - und zum Knochenbilden braucht man Salze, die Knochen bestehen aus kohlensaurem Kalk, phosphorsaurem Kalk; Salze sind das -, daraus sehen Sie, daß man die Wurzel braucht, um den menschlichen Kopf zu versorgen.
Also, meine Herren, wenn man zum Beispiel merkt, sagen wir, daß ein Kind schwach wird im Kopf, woran können Sie das merken? Man kann das manchmal an entsprechenden Zuständen merken: Wenn ein Kind im Kopf schwach wird, dann kriegt es leicht Würmer im Gedärm. Würmer halten sich im Gedärm auf, wenn die Kopfkräfte zu schwach sind, weil dann der Kopf nicht stark genug in den übrigen Körper herunterwirkt, während die Würmer keine Behausung im Menschen finden, wenn die Kopfkräfte stark in die Gedärme herunter wirken. Daraus können Sie am allerbesten sehen, wie großartig der menschliche Körper eingerichtet ist: Alles hängt in ihm zusammen. Und wenn man ein Kind hat, das Würmer hat, soll man sich sagen, das Kind ist im Kopf schwach; man kann auch sagen — namentlich derjenige, der Pädagoge sein will, muß solche Dinge wissen —, wenn man später im Leben Menschen hat, die kopfschwach sind, so haben sie in der Jugend ihre Würmer gehabt. - Was muß man denn da tun, wenn man das beobachtet? Nun, meine Herren, das einfachste ist, wenn man Gelbe Rüben nimmt, Möhren, und füttert die Kinder eine Zeitlang damit — unter anderem; natürlich darf man sie nicht nur mit Gelben Rüben anfüttern, aber eine Zeitlang. Gelbe Rüben sind ja dasjenige, was vorzugsweise Pflanzenwurzel in der Erde ist. Die haben viel Salze; die sind imstande, da sie die Kräfte der Erde haben, wenn sie aufgenommen werden in den Magen, durch das Blut bis in den Kopf wieder zu wirken. Nur salzreiche Stoffe sind fähig, in den Kopf zu dringen. Salzreiche Stoffe, wurzelhafte Stoffe machen den Menschen durch den Kopf stark. Das ist dasjenige, sehen Sie, was außerordentlich wichtig ist. Und gerade bei den Gelben Rüben, bei den Möhren, da ist es so, daß die allerobersten Partien des Kopfes stark werden, also dasjenige, was man gerade braucht für den Menschen, damit er innerlich kräftig, steif wird, damit er nicht weichlich wird.
Sehen Sie, wenn Sie die Pflanze von einer Gelben Rübe anschauen, so werden Sie sich sagen: Der Pflanze sehe ich etwas ganz Bestimmtes an, die ist vorzugsweise zu der Wurzel hingewachsen. Es ist ja fast alles Wurzel an der Gelben Rübe. Man interessiert sich nur für die Wurzel, wenn man die Pflanze hat. Das andere, das Kraut, ist nur so obenauf, hat nicht viel Bedeutung. Also diese Gelbe Rübe ist vorzugsweise geeignet, den menschlichen Kopf als ein Nahrungsmittel zu versorgen. Wenn Sie daher manchmal fühlen, Sie haben so eine Kopfschwäche, eine Leere im Gehirn, können nicht gut denken, dann ist es auch gut, wenn Sie sich Gelbe Rüben einmal eine Zeitlang in die Nahrung tun. Aber am meisten hilft das natürlich bei Kindern.
Nun, wenn Sie jetzt aber die Kartoffel vergleichen mit der Gelben Rübe - ja sehen Sie, die schaut ganz anders aus als die Gelbe Rübe. Sie wissen ja, die Kartoffel hat Kraut, aber sie hat dann gerade das, was man ißt, diese Knollen; die stecken in der Erde drinnen. Nun kann man, wenn man oberflächlich die Sache betrachtet, sagen: Bei der Kartoffel sind diese Knollen die Wurzeln. Das ist aber nicht wahr; diese Knollen sind keine Wurzeln. Wenn Sie nämlich genauer zuschauen, so werden Sie überall sehen: Da hängen eigentlich erst die Wurzeln daran an den Knollen in der Erde. Die eigentlichen Wurzeln sind kleine Würzelchen, die daranhängen an den Knollen; sie fallen nur leicht ab. Wenn man die Kartoffeln ausnimmt, sind sie. schon abgefallen; aber wenn man sie ganz frisch ausnimmt, sind sie überall noch dran. Wenn wir die Knollen nehmen und essen, haben wir schon so etwas wie Stengel oder Kraut, das sich nur scheinbar wie Wurzeln ausbildet; in Wirklichkeit ist das ein Stengel oder ein Kraut; die Blätter sind umgestaltet. Das ist also etwas, was zwischen der Wurzel und dem Kraut drinnen ist. Daher hat die Kartoffel nicht so viel Salze in sich wie zum Beispiel die Rübe, ist nicht so erdenhaft; sie wächst zwar in der Erde, aber sie ist nicht so verwandt mit dem Erdigen. Und die Kartoffel, die hat vorzugsweise Kohlehydrate, nicht so viel Salze, aber Kohlehydrate.
Jetzt müssen Sie sich folgendes sagen: Wenn ich Gelbe Rüben esse, dann kann mein Körper eigentlich ein richtiger Faulenzer sein, denn er braucht nur den Mundsaft, den Speichel zu verwenden bei der Gelben Rübe, um sie aufzuweichen im Speichel; er braucht nur den Magensaft zu verwenden, das Pepsin und so weiter, und die ganze wichtige Sache von der Gelben Rübe geht in den Kopf. Der Mensch braucht die Salze. Diese Salze werden geliefert durch alles das, was Pflanzenwurzel ist, und im besonderen Maß von einer solchen Wurzel wie der Gelben Rübe.
Nun, wenn der Mensch aber Kartoffeln ißt, gibt er sie auch zunächst in den Mund, in den Magen; da wird aus der Kartoffel erst durch die Anstrengung des Leibes Stärke gebildet. Dann geht es weiter durch den Darm. Damit es bei weiterer Verdauung bis ins Blut geht und auch in den Kopf kommen kann, muß wiederum eine Anstrengung gemacht werden, daß aus der Stärke Zucker gewonnen wird. Dann erst kann es in den Kopf gehen. Da muß man also eine größere Kraft anwenden. Ja, sehen Sie, meine Herren, wenn ich auf etwas Äußerliches eine Kraft anwenden soll, dann werde ich schwach. Das ist ja das Geheimnis des Menschen: Wenn ich Holz hacke, also wenn ich äußerlich eine Kraft anwende, dann werde ich schwach. Wenn ich aber innerlich eine Kraft in mir ausbilde, daß ich Kohlehydrate in Stärke und Stärke in Zucker verwandle, da werde ich stark. Gerade indem ich das ausführe, daß ich mich selber mit Zucker durchsetze, dadurch daß ich Kartoffeln esse, werde ich stark. Wenn ich äußerlich Kraft anwende, werde ich schwach; wenn ich innerlich Kraft anwende, werde ich stark. Es kommt also nicht darauf an, daß man sich mit Nahrungsmitteln nur ausfüllt, sondern daß die Nahrungsmittel im Körper Kräfte entwickeln.
So daß man also sagen kann: Wurzelnahrung — denn alle Wurzeln sind so, nur nicht in demselben Grade wie die Rübenwurzel, daß sie vorzugsweise auf den Kopf wirken -, Wurzelnahrung, die gibt dem Körper dasjenige, was er für sich braucht. Nahrung, die schon ein bißchen nur nach dem Kraut neigt, Kohlehydrate hat, die gibt dem Körper Kräfte, die er zum Arbeiten braucht, zur Bewegung braucht.
Nun, über die Kartoffel habe ich schon gesprochen; sie macht den Menschen zugleich, indem sie wiederum furchtbar viel Kraftaufwand braucht, wieder schwach, und macht ihn vor allen Dingen so, daß er nicht auf die Dauer Kräfte bekommt. Aber das Prinzip, das ich Ihnen jetzt auseinandergesetzt habe, gilt gerade eben für die Kartoffel.
Aber in demselben Maße wie die Kartoffel im schlechteren Sinne, sind im guten Sinne alle die Saatfrüchte Nahrungsmittel: Weizen oder Roggen und so weiter. Da drinnen sind nun auch die Kohlehydrate, und zwar so, daß der Mensch in der günstigsten Weise Stärke bereitet, Zucker bereitet, sich also eigentlich durch die Kohlehydrate der Feldfrüchte so stark machen kann, als es nur möglich ist. - Denken Sie nur einmal, wie stark gerade die Leute auf dem Lande werden dadurch, daß sie einfach viel von ihrem Brot essen, in dem die Feldfrüchte drinnen sind! Sie müssen nur an sich schon gesunde Körper haben; gerade wenn man gröberes Brot verträgt, ist es eigentlich die allergesündeste Nahrung. Sie müssen gesunde Körper haben; aber dann wird gerade der Körper durch die Stärke- und Zuckerbereitung ganz besonders stark.
Nun entsteht ja eine Frage. Sehen Sie, die Menschen sind ganz von selber, möchte man sagen, darauf gekommen in ihrer Entwickelung, die Feldfrüchte nicht so zu essen wie die Tiere. Das Roß frißt seinen Hafer fast wie er wächst. Die Tiere fressen ihre Körnerfrüchte so, wie sie wachsen. Denn die Vögel müßten schlecht Körnerfrüchte essen können, wenn sie darauf angewiesen wären, daß sie ihnen jemand erst kochte! Die Menschen sind von selber darauf gekommen, sich die Feldfrüchte zu kochen. Meine Herren, was geschieht denn dadurch, daß ich die Feldfrüchte koche? Sehen Sie, dadurch, daß ich die Feldfrüchte koche, genieße ich sie nicht kalt, sondern warm. Nun müssen wir, wenn wir die Nahrung innerlich verarbeiten wollen, Wärme aufwenden. Das geht nicht ohne Wärme ab, meine Herren, daß man Kohlehydrate in Stärke und Stärke in Zucker verwandelt; das bedarf eines innerlichen Heizens. Wenn ich nun schon außen heize und die Nahrungsmittel schon warm mache, dann komme ich dem Körper zu Hilfe; dann braucht er die Wärme nicht von sich selber abzugeben. Also erstens werden die Nahrungsmittel dadurch schon in den Feuer-, in den Wärmeprozeß aufgenommen, daß man sie kocht. Das ist das erste. Das zweite ist aber: die Nahrungsmittel werden da ganz verändert! Denken Sie nur, was aus dem Mehl gemacht wird, wenn ich es zu Brot verbacke. Es wird ja ganz anders! Aber durch was wird es anders? Nun, zunächst mahle ich die Früchte. Was heißt mahlen? Ganz klein machen. — Ja, sehen Sie, das, was ich da tue mit den Körnerfrüchten, daß ich sie mahle, ganz klein mache, das müßte ich ja später in meinem eigenen Leib tun! Alles das, was ich da mache, müßte ich in meinem eigenen Leib tun; durch das, was ich da mache, nehme ich es dem Leib ab. Ebenso wenn ich sie röste. Alle diese Dinge, die ich beim Kochen ausführe, die nehme ich dem Leib ab, so daß ich die Nahrungsmittel dann in einen Zustand bringe, in dem der Körper sie leichter verdaut.
Sie brauchen ja nur zu vergleichen, was für ein Unterschied bestehen würde, wenn der Mensch rohe Kartoffeln essen würde, oder wenn er sie gekocht ißt. Wenn der Mensch rohe Kartoffeln essen würde, müßte der Magen ungeheuer viel Wärme hergeben, um diese rohe Kartoffel, die fast schon Stärke ist, umzuändern. Wie er sie jetzt umändert, das ist aber nicht hinreichend. Die Kartoffel geht dann in den Darm. Der Darm muß wiederum viel Kraft aufwenden. Dadurch aber bleibt die Kartoffel überhaupt im Darm stecken; die späteren Kräfte sind nicht mehr geeignet, die Kartoffel weiterzuleiten in den übrigen Körper. Ißt man also rohe Kartoffeln, so füllt man sich entweder bloß den Magen an - und der Darm kann schon nicht mehr weiter was damit anfangen —, oder man füllt sich den Darm an; aber weiter geht es nicht. Bereitet man aber die Kartoffel vor, indem man sie kocht oder irgendwie anders zubereitet, hat der Magen nicht mehr so viel damit zu tun, der Darm auch nicht; die Kartoffeln gehen über ins Blut und gehen bis in den Kopf.
Also Sie sehen, man hat dadurch, daß man die Speisen kocht, insbesondere daß man diejenigen Speisen kocht, welche auf die Kohlehydrate berechnet sind, die Möglichkeit, die Ernährung zu unterstützen.
Sie wissen ja, in der neueren Zeit sind allerlei Narrheiten gekommen, besonders in bezug auf die Ernährung. Die Narrheiten sind ja heute eigentlich Mode. Da gibt es «Rohköstler», die wollen überhaupt nichts mehr kochen, die wollen durchaus alles bloß roh essen. - Nun, natürlich, aus was kommt so etwas? Weil die Leute aus der materialistischen Wissenschaft nicht mehr wissen, wie die Sachen sind, und eine geistige Wissenschaft wollen sie nicht kennenlernen. Daher denken sie sich etwas aus. Die ganze Rohköstlerei ist nichts als eine Phantasterei. Eine Zeitlang kann man schon, weil der Körper starke Kräfte aufwenden muß, ich möchte sagen, den Körper aufpeitschen, wenn man bloß Rohkost benützt; aber um so mehr fällt er dann zusammen.
Nun, meine Herren, kommen wir jetzt zu den Fetten überhaupt. Die Pflanzen, fast alle Pflanzen enthalten Fette, Pflanzenfette, die sich die Pflanzen aus den Mineralien bereiten. Ja, sehen Sie, die Fette, die kommen nicht so leicht in den menschlichen Körper hinein wie die Kohlehydrate und die Salze. Die Salze werden eigentlich gar nicht verändert. Wenn Sie sich Ihre Suppe salzen: das Salz, das Sie da reinschmeißen, das geht fast unverändert in Ihren Kopf als Salz hinauf; Sie kriegen das in den Kopf hinein. Wenn Sie aber Kartoffeln essen, so kriegen Sie in Ihren Kopf schon nicht mehr Kartoffeln hinein, sondern Zucker; aber die Verwandlung geht so vor sich, wie ich es Ihnen gesagt habe. Bei den Fetten aber, gleichgültig, ob Sie pflanzliche oder tierische Fette essen, da geht die Sache nicht so einfach. Bei den Fetten ist es so: Wenn Sie die Fette essen, dann werden sie durch den Mundsaft, Magensaft, Darmsaft überhaupt fast ganz aufgegessen, und es geht ganz was anderes ins Blut über, und das Tier und der Mensch muß sich durch die Kraft, welche die Fette hervorrufen, im Darm und im Blut erst selber die Fette bilden.
Sehen Sie, das ist der Unterschied zwischen dem Fett und zwischen Zucker oder Salz. Salz und Zucker nimmt der Mensch eigentlich noch aus der Natur auf, nur daß er sich den Zucker aus der Kartoffel oder aus dem Roggen und so weiter verwandelt. Da hat er noch etwas von der Natur drinnen. Bei dem Fett, das der Mensch oder das Tier in sich hat, ist nichts mehr Natur; das hat er sich selber gebildet. Aber er hätte keine Kraft, wenn er sich nicht ernähren würde, und Darm und Blutansatz brauchen Fett. So daß man sagen kann: Salze könnte der Mensch nicht selber bilden. Der menschliche Körper würde, wenn er nicht Salze aufnehmen würde, niemals sich von selber Salze bilden. Wenn der Mensch nicht Kohlehydrate aufnehmen würde, wenn er nicht Brot oder so etwas essen würde, wodurch er Kohlehydrate aufnimmt, würde er nicht Zucker bilden können. Wenn er aber nicht Zucker bilden könnte, würde er ewig ein Schwachmatikus sein. Das verdanken Sie nur dem Zucker, meine Herren: Weil Sie durch und durch voll Süßigkeit sind, haben Sie Kraft. In dem Augenblicke, wo Sie nicht mehr durch und durch voll Süßigkeit wären, würden Sie nicht mehr Kraft haben, würden Sie zusammensinken.
- Sehen Sie, das geht bis in die Völker hinein. Wir haben Völker, welche wenig Zucker verzehren und auch wenig Stoffe, die Zucker bereiten. Das sind schwache Völker in bezug auf physische Kräfte. Wir haben Völker, die viel Zucker essen; das sind starke Völker.
Aber so leicht hat es der Mensch mit den Fetten nicht. Wenn der Mensch Fette hat in sich, das Tier auch, so ist das sein eigenes Verdienst, das Verdienst seines Körpers. Die Fette sind ganz sein eigenes Produkt. So daß also der Mensch das, was er an Fetten in sich aufnimmt von außen durch Pflanzenfette, durch tierische Fette, vernichtet, und in der Überwindung der Fette entwickelt er jetzt die Kraft. Bei der Kartoffel, beim Roggen, beim Weizen, da entwickelt der Mensch seine Kräfte, indem er die Stoffe verwandelt; bei den Fetten, die er ißt, entwickelt er die Kraft, indem er die Stoffe vernichtet. Wenn ich von außen irgend etwas vernichte, werde ich wieder müde und matt. Wenn ich aber im Inneren ein ganz fettes Beefsteak vernichte, werde ich dadurch schwach, aber diese Vernichtung des ganz fetten Beefsteaks oder die Vernichtung von Pflanzenfett, das gibt mir wiederum Kraft, daß ich das eigene Fett entwickeln kann, wenn mein Körper dazu veranlagt ist. So sehen Sie also, daß die Fettnahrung auf ganz andere Art im menschlichen Körper wirkt als die Kohlehydratnahrung.
Nun, meine Herren, der menschliche Körper ist ja recht kompliziert, und man muß schon sagen, das, was ich Ihnen da erzähle, das ist eine große Arbeit; es muß viel geschehen im menschlichen Leib, daß er diese Pflanzenfette vernichten kann. Nehmen wir aber jetzt an, der Mensch genießt Kraut, also von der Pflanze das Krautartige. Ja, das ist schon so: Wo das Krautartige genossen wird, da ist dasjenige da, was der Mensch namentlich an Fetten von der Pflanze bekommt. Wodurch ist denn der Halm so ein hartes Zeug? Weil er die Blätter umbildet, so daß sie zu Kohlehydraten werden. Wenn aber die Blätter grün bleiben - je grüner sie sind, desto mehr geben sie eben fettige Substanz. So daß also der Mensch, wenn er Brot ißt, sagen wir, vom Brot nicht viel Fett aufnimmt in sich. Er nimmt zum Beispiel von dem, was, sagen wir, Brunnenkresse ist — die kleine Pflanze mit den ganz kleinen Blättern —, mehr Fett auf, als wenn er Brot ißt. Es ist daher ein Bedürfnis entstanden, daß man das Brot mit Butter, mit etwas Fett ißt, nicht für sich, oder wie die Landleute mit Speck und so weiter, was ja wiederum Fett ist, da ist dann für zweierlei gesorgt.
Wenn ich Brot esse, so geht das Brot dadurch, daß das Wurzelhafte der Pflanze bis in den Halm hinaufgeht — denn der Halm, der hat die Wurzelkräfte, trotzdem er Halm ist und oben in der Luft wächst, in sich -, bis in den Kopf hinauf. Es kommt nicht darauf an, ob etwas oben in der Luft ist, sondern ob es wurzelhaft ist. Aber das Blatt, das grüne Blatt ist nicht wurzelhaft. Drunten in der Erde entsteht kein grünes Blatt. Im Herbst, wenn die Sonnenkräfte nicht mehr stark wirken, da kann der Halm ausreifen, gegen den Spätsommer und Herbst zu. Aber die stärksten Triebkräfte der Sonne braucht das Blatt, wenn es reifen soll; das wächst der Sonne zu. So daß wir sagen können: Das Kraut wirkt vorzugsweise auf Lunge und Herz, während also die Wurzel den Kopf stark macht und auch noch die Kartoffel so ist, daß sie eigentlich bis zum Kopfe kommt. Wenn wir das Kraut essen, das vorzugsweise Pflanzenfette uns geben kann, machen wir uns in Herz und Lunge stark, im mittleren Menschen, im Brustmenschen. Das ist, möchte ich sagen, das Geheimnis der menschlichen Ernährung: Will ich auf meinen Kopf wirken, dann bereite ich mir Wurzelnahrung oder Halmnahrung oder so etwas zu; will ich auf Lunge und Herz wirken, mache ich mir Salat und so weiter. Weil aber diese Dinge schon im Darm vernichtet werden und nur die Kräfte wirken, braucht man da nicht so viel zu kochen. Daher werden die Blätter zu Salaten gemacht. Aber alles das, was im Kopfe wirken soll, das kann nicht zu Salaten gemacht werden, das muß verkocht werden. Gekochte Nahrung wirkt vorzugsweise bis in den Kopf. Salatartige Nahrung wirkt vorzugsweise auf Lunge, Herz und so weiter aufbauend, also ernährend hinein, und zwar durch die Fette.
Nun ist es aber so, meine Herren, daß man nicht nur auf den Kopf wirken muß und auf den mittleren, auf den Brustmenschen, sondern der Mensch muß ja auch die Nahrungsorgane selber aufgebaut haben. Er braucht einen Magen, ein Gedärm, er braucht Nieren, die Leber, und er muß also die Nahrungsorgane selber aufgebaut haben. Nun ist das Interessante: Zum Aufbauen der Nahrungsorgane braucht der Mensch als Ernährung gerade das Eiweiß, das Eiweiß in den Pflanzen, und zwar vorzugsweise wie es in den Pflanzen enthalten ist in der Blüte, und namentlich in der Frucht selber. So daß wir sagen können: Die Wurzel ernährt vorzugsweise den Kopf (siehe Zeichnung, Seite 97); das, was in der Mitte der Pflanze ist, das Kraut, ernährt vorzugsweise die Brust, und das, was in den Früchten ist, den Unterleib.
Schauen wir also auf unsere Saatfelder, so können wir sagen: Gut, daß die da sind, denn davon wird unser Kopf genährt. Schauen wir auf den Salat, den wir anpflanzen, auf alles dasjenige, was wir in den Blättern essen, was wir nicht zu kochen brauchen, weil es schon in den Därmen verdaut werden kann, weil es nur auf die Kräfte ankommt, dann bekommen wir alles das, was uns unsere Brustorgane erhält. Aber gucken wir hinauf auf die Pflaumen, Apfel, Früchte, die an den Bäumen wachsen - ja sehen Sie, da brauchen wir nicht viel zu kochen, denn ‚ die werden schon im ganzen Sommer von der Sonne selber ausgekocht! Also da wird schon die innere Reifung bewirkt; da ist es anders als bei Wurzeln und bei dem, was also nicht von der Sonne ausgereift wird, sondern verdorrt wie Halme und so weiter. Bei den Früchten, da brauchen wir nicht viel zu kochen, sondern nur dann, wenn wir einen schwachen Organismus haben, der im Darm die Früchte nicht vernichten kann, müssen wir kochen, Kompotte machen und dergleichen. Also gerade wenn jemand Darmkrankheiten hat, muß er dafür sorgen, daß er die Früchte in Kompottform bekommt, als Brei, Mus und so weiter. Aber wenn einer ein ganz gesundes Verdauungssystem hat, ein ganz gesundes Darmsystem, dann sind die Früchte gerade dazu da, den Unterleib aufzubauen, und zwar durch das, was sie ‚an Eiweiß in sich haben. Eiweiß in den Pflanzenfrüchten baut Ihnen Ihren Magen auf, baut alles dasjenige auf, was der Mensch im Unterleib als Ernährungsorgane selber hat.
Sehen Sie, was eigentlich für ein Instinkt immer da war! Die Menschen haben natürlich das, was ich Ihnen jetzt auseinandersetze, nicht so mit Begriffen gewußt, aber sie haben es aus dem Instinkt gewußt. Daher haben sie eigentlich immer sich eine gemischte Nahrung zubereitet aus Wurzeln, Kraut und Früchten, haben alle diese Dinge gegessen, und auch auf die Mengen, die man zum einen oder zum anderen braucht, sind sie aus dem Instinkt gekommen.
Nun wissen Sie aber, daß die Menschen nicht bloß Pflanzen essen, sondern auch Tiere, Fleisch von Tieren, Fett von Tieren genießen und so weiter.
Sehen Sie, die Anthroposophie ist nirgends dazu da, fanatisch oder sektenhaft aufzutreten, sondern nur, um zu sagen, wie die Dinge sind. Und man kann nicht sagen, daß der Mensch nur Pflanzen essen soll, oder auch Tierisches essen soll und so weiter, sondern man muß folgendes sagen: Es gibt einfach Menschen, die können durch alle die Kräfte, die sie in sich durch die Vererbung haben, nicht so viel Kräfte aufbringen, daß sie alle die Arbeit verrichten können, um Pflanzenfette soweit zu vernichten, daß die Kräfte wiederum entstehen im Leib, um eigenes Fett zu erzeugen. Sehen Sie, wer nur Pflanzenfette ißt, ja, meine Herren, das ist ein Mensch, der entweder darauf verzichten muß, ein dicker Kerl zu werden, weil das Pflanzenfett vernichtet wird — und aus der Vernichtung entstehen Kräfte —, oder aber er muß eine furchtbar gute Gesundheit in der Verdauung haben, daß es ihm leicht wird, die Pflanzenfette zu vernichten; dann kriegt er Kräfte, um eigenes Fett anzusetzen. Die meisten Menschen aber sind so, daß sie eigentlich das gar nicht durchführen können, eigenes Fett genügend anzusetzen, wenn sie nur Pflanzenfett vernichten. Wenn die Menschen aber tierisches Fett essen oder Fleisch, wird das nicht ganz vernichtet. Pflanzenfett geht nicht über die Gedärme heraus, wird in den Gedärmen vernichtet; das Fett aber, das im Fleisch enthalten ist, geht wieder in den Menschen über. Und er darf schwächer sein - schwächer, als wenn er sich bloß mit dem Pflanzenfett ernährt. Daher werden wir unterscheiden zwischen solchen Körpern, die nicht gern das Fett haben, Körpern, die nicht gern Speck essen, die insbesondere fette Nahrungsmittel nicht gern mögen; das sind solche Körper, die verhältnismäßig leicht das Fett vernichten und dadurch Fett in sich selber bilden wollen. Die Körper sagen: Was ich an mir trage an Speck, das will ich mir selber machen; meinen eigenen Speck will ich haben. -— Wenn aber einer sich die Tafel ganz voll setzt mit fetten Speisen, dann sagt er nicht: Meinen Speck will ich selber machen -, sondern dann sagt er: Die Welt soll mir meinen Speck geben -, denn das tierische Fett geht in den Leib über. Das ist also eine Erleichterung in der Ernährung.
Wenn das Kind Zucker schleckt, tut es das ja nicht wegen der Ernährung. Es ist schon etwas Nahrhaftes drinnen, wenn die Kinder Zucker schlecken, aber das Kind tut das ja nicht wegen der Ernährung, sondern wegen der Süße. Nun, da wird die Süßigkeit bewußt beim Zuckerschlecken. Wenn der Mensch aber das Fett vom Ochsen, vom Schwein, oder was es halt ist, in sich aufnimmt - ja, meine Herren, da geht das über in seinen Körper. Das befriedigt seine Wollust geradeso, wie das Zuckerschlecken die Wollust des Kindes befriedigt, nur daß es nicht so befriedigt, aber der Mensch fühlt schon, daß da Wollust drinnen ist. Nun braucht der Mensch natürlich zu seinem inneren Dasein diese innere Wollust. Daher liebt er das Fleisch. Fleisch ißt man also besonders, wenn der Körper das Fleisch liebt. |
Aber man darf in dieser Beziehung nicht fanatisch sein. Es gibt Menschen, die können gar nicht bestehen, wenn sie kein Fleisch essen. Es muß daher immer sorgfältig ausprobiert werden, ob sie wirklich ohne Fleisch leben können. Aber wenn einer ohne Fleisch auskommen kann, fühlt er sich dann, wenn er von der Fleischnahrung übergeht zu der vegetarischen Nahrung, stärker als vorher. Sehen Sie, das ist eben die Schwierigkeit: Mancher verträgt gar nicht zu leben ohne Fleisch. Wenn er aber das kann, so fühlt er sich dann stärker, wenn er Vegetarier geworden ist, weil er nicht mehr darauf angewiesen ist, fremdes Fett in sich abzulagern, sondern nur sein eigenes Fett kriegt; in dem fühlt er sich dann stark.
Und ich kann schon sagen: Das weiß ich von mir selber, der ich die Anstrengungen, die ich seit langer Zeit, die ich in den letzten vierundzwanzig Jahren habe durchmachen müssen, daß ich die anders nicht hätte durchmachen können! Dann würde ich nicht ganze Nächte haben fahren können und am nächsten Tag einen Vortrag halten und so weiter. Denn, nicht wahr, es wird einem das, was man sich selber bereiten muß, wenn man Vegetarier ist, abgenommen, wenn man sich durch das Tier zuerst diese Arbeit verrichten läßt. Das ist die Geschichte. Sie dürfen aber nicht glauben, daß ich in irgendeiner Weise für den Vegetarismus agitiere, weil es wirklich immer erst ausprobiert werden muß, ob der betreffende Mensch überhaupt Vegetarier werden kann oder nicht; das ist seine Anlage.
Sehen Sie, meine Herren, besonders wichtig ist das ja beim Eiweiß. Eiweiß kann man auch umgestalten, wenn man in der Lage ist, es so, wie man es aufnimmt als Pflanzeneiweiß, im Gedärm zu vernichten; und dann bekommt man die Kräfte. Aber sobald das Gedärm schwach wird, muß man es schon von außen bereiten, also richtig Eiweiß aufnehmen, was ja dann zum Beispiel tierisches Eiweiß ist, denn die Hühner, die die Eier liefern, sind ja auch Tiere. Nun, das Eiweiß, das ist etwas, was eigentlich wirklich ganz falsch beurteilt wird, wenn man die Sache nicht geisteswissenschaftlich beurteilt.
Wenn ich Wurzeln esse, so kommen ihre Salze bis in meinen Kopf. Wenn ich Salat esse, so kommen die Kräfte - nicht die Fette selber, aber die Kräfte, die von den Fetten in den Pflanzen sind - in meine Brust, Lunge und Herz. Wenn ich Früchte esse, so kommt das Eiweiß aus den Früchten aber nicht bis in die Brust, sondern bleibt im Gedärm. Und das Eiweiß nun, das man aus dem Tierischen hat, das geht weiter als ins Gedärm, das versorgt den Körper, weil das Eiweiß von den Tieren sich ausbreitet. So könnte man sagen: Wenn der Mensch besonders viel Eiweiß ißt, so muß er ein gut genährter Mensch werden. Das hat dazu geführt, daß im materialistischen Zeitalter die Leute, die Medizin studiert hatten, den Leuten übertriebenen Eiweißgenuß angeraten haben; man hat behauptet, daß hundertzwanzig bis hundertfünfzig Gramm Eiweiß notwendig sind. Unsinn ist das! Heute weiß man, daß nur ein Viertel davon für den Menschen notwendig ist. Und tatsächlich, wenn der Mensch so furchtbar viel Eiweiß ißt, was unnötig ist — ja, sehen Sie, dann kommt es eben so, wie es einmal einem Professor gegangen ist mit seinem Assistenten: Die haben einen Menschen, der unterernährt war, mit Eiweiß auffüttern wollen. Nun setzt man voraus, daß das Eiweiß, wenn es besonders viel ist, umgewandelt wird im Menschen, und daß sich im Urin zeigt, daß er Eiweiß gegessen hat. Nun kamen sie bei diesem Menschen darauf: Der Urin zeigt nicht, daß das Eiweiß im Körper drinnen verarbeitet ist. Sie kamen nicht darauf, daß durch den Darm Eiweiß abging. Der Professor war ganz wild darüber. Und der Assistent sagte mit schlotternden Beinen ängstlich: Ja, Herr Professor, vielleicht durch den Darm? — Ja, was war geschehen? Die haben den Mann mit Eiweiß überfüttert, aber das hat ihm nichts genützt, denn das Eiweiß ist vom Magen in den Darm gegangen, und dann wiederum hinten heraus. Es ist also gar nicht in den Körper gegangen. Wenn man zuviel Eiweiß füttert, so geht es gar nicht in den Körper, sondern in die Fäkalien. - Aber etwas hat er doch davon, denn bevor es herausgeht, bleibt es im Darm liegen und wird zu Gift und intoxiert den ganzen Körper, vergiftet den Körper! Das hat man von zuviel Eiweiß. Und von dieser Vergiftung entsteht sehr häufig die Arterienverkalkung, so daß viele Menschen die Arterienverkalkung zu früh kriegen - sie einfach deshalb kriegen, weil sie mit Eiweiß überfüttert werden.
Also es ist schon wichtig, so wie ich es gerade auseinandergesetzt habe, die Ernährungsfrage kennenzulernen. Denn die meisten Menschen sind eigentlich sehr häufig der Ansicht: man wird um so besser ernährt, je mehr man ißt. Das ist nicht richtig, sondern man wird manchmal viel besser ernährt, wenn man weniger ißt, weil man dann sich nicht vergiftet.
Und das ist es: Man muß wissen, wie diese einzelnen Stoffe wirken. Man muß wissen, daß also Salze vorzugsweise auf den Kopf wirken, daß Kohlehydrate, wie sie also in unseren Hauptnahrungsmitteln, in Brot und in den Kartoffeln sind, mehr auf das Lungensystem und auf das Halssystem — Lunge, Hals, Gaumen und so weiter — wirken, daß Fette vorzugsweise wirken auf Herz und Blutgefäße, Arterien und Venen, und daß das Eiweiß vorzugsweise wirkt auf die Unterleibsorgane. Der Kopf hat überhaupt nichts besonderes vom Eiweiß. Das Eiweiß, das im Kopfe ist — natürlich muß der Kopf auch aus Eiweiß aufgebaut werden, denn er besteht ja aus lebendiger Substanz -, das Eiweiß muß sich der Mensch auch selber bilden. Wenn man ihn also überfüttert, so darf man nicht glauben, daß er dadurch ein besonders gesundes Hirn kriegt, sondern im Gegenteil, er kriegt ein vergiftetes Hirn.
Ich werde vielleicht noch eine Stunde über die Ernährung reden müssen. Es ist dies aber ganz schön, weil solche Fragen ganz fruchtbar sind. Also dann nächsten Samstag um neun Uhr.
Eiweiß: Unterleibsorgane
Fette: Herz und Blutgefäße
Kohlehydrate: Lunge, Hals, Gaumen
Salze: Kopf
Sixth Lecture
Good morning! Well, gentlemen, has anyone prepared a question during this long period?
Mr. Burle: I would like to ask the doctor about food—about beans, yellow beets, and so on, what effect they have on the body? The doctor has already talked about potatoes. Perhaps we can hear something about other foods. Some vegetarians do not eat hanging things, such as beans and peas. When you see a cornfield, for example, it gives you different thoughts about the bread fruit, which most likely all peoples of the earth have, with variations.
Dr. Steiner: So, it is desired that something should now be said about the relationship between food and human beings. Well, it is necessary to first clarify what nutrition is actually based on. One might initially imagine that nutrition is based on humans ingesting food, bringing it into the stomach through the mouth, where it is then stored in the body, excreted, and then consumed again, and so on. But it's not that simple; things are much more complicated than that. And if we want to understand how humans actually relate to food, we first need to understand what kind of food humans absolutely need.
You see, the first thing humans need, the first thing they absolutely must consume, is protein. So humans absolutely need protein. Let's write that down so we have everything together. So, protein, as found in chicken eggs, for example; but not only in chicken eggs, protein is found in all foods. Humans absolutely need protein. The second thing humans need is fat. Again, fat is found in all foods. There are also fats in plants. The third has a name that you may be less familiar with, but which you should know: carbohydrates. Carbohydrates are substances that are found in abundance in potatoes, for example, but there are also many carbohydrates in all other plants. Carbohydrates are special in that when you eat them, they are slowly converted into starch by the saliva in your mouth and the gastric juice in your stomach. Starch is something that humans definitely need, but they don't eat starch; instead, they eat foods that contain carbohydrates, which are then converted into starch in the body. And then, during further digestion, they are converted once again into sugar. And humans need sugar. So carbohydrates provide them with sugar.
But there is something else that humans need: the salts they consume. They consume some of these as additives to food, but some salts are already contained in all foods.
When we consider protein, we must take into account the great difference between animals and humans compared to plants. Plants also contain protein, but they do not eat protein. But if plants still have protein in them, where do they get it from? They get it from the soil, the air, from the inanimate, from the mineral; they can prepare their protein from the inanimate, from the mineral. Neither animals nor humans can do this. Humans cannot produce protein from inanimate matter — they would then only be plants — but must absorb protein that has already been produced by plants or animals.
In general, humans need plants in order to live on Earth. And plants — now this is the interesting thing — could not thrive if humans were not there! And it is interesting, gentlemen, you only have to consider that the two most important things for life are: the green plant sap in the green leaves and, on the other hand, blood. This green in the plant sap is called chlorophyll, leaf green; so chlorophyll is contained in the green leaf. And blood is also important. Now, there is something very peculiar: you see, when you look at human beings, they first breathe — breathing is also a form of nutrition — they take oxygen from the air, they breathe in oxygen. But carbon is deposited throughout their entire body, everywhere. If you go into the earth where there is a coal deposit, you will find black coal; if you sharpen a pencil, you will find graphite. Coal and graphite are carbon. They consist entirely of carbon, except for other substances, throughout the entire body; it is formed in the human body.
Now you might say: Yes, humans are actually quite black Rapuzzel, especially in relation to carbon! But you can also say something else: you see, the most expensive substance in the world, the diamond, also consists of carbon, only in a different form! So if you prefer, you can also say: in terms of carbon, you consist entirely of diamonds. The dark carbon, the graphite in the pencil, and the diamond are the same substance. If the coal you dig out of the earth can be made transparent by some artifice, then it is diamond. So we have these diamonds deposited everywhere within us. We are a veritable coal deposit. But when oxygen combines with carbon in the blood, carbonic acid is formed. You are also very familiar with carbonic acid: you only need to take seltzer water; there are bubbles in it — these are carbon dioxide, which is a gas. So you can imagine: humans breathe oxygen from the air, the oxygen spreads through the entire bloodstream, in the blood it absorbs carbon, and it exhales carbon dioxide. You breathe in oxygen and breathe out carbon dioxide.
Gentlemen, in the processes I have described to you in the development of the Earth, everything would long since have been poisoned by carbon dioxide from humans and animals. For it has been a long time since everything developed on Earth. As you can see, animals and humans would have been unable to live on Earth for a long time if plants did not have a completely different property: plants do not absorb oxygen, but rather the carbon dioxide that humans and animals exhale. So plants are just as greedy for carbon dioxide as humans are for oxygen.
And now you have the plant (see drawing): roots, stems, leaves, flowers, so the plant absorbs carbon dioxide everywhere; it goes in. And now the carbon in the carbon dioxide settles in the plant, and the oxygen is exhaled by the plants. Then humans and animals have it again. Humans release carbon dioxide and kill everything; plants retain the carbon, release the oxygen, and thus enliven everything. And the plant could do nothing with the carbon dioxide if it weren't for the green plant sap, chlorophyll. This green plant sap, gentlemen, is a magician that retains the carbon in the plant and releases the oxygen again. The blood combines oxygen with carbon; the green plant sap takes the carbon out of the carbon dioxide and releases the oxygen.
Think what a wonderful thing it is in nature that plants, humans, and animals complement each other in this way! They complement each other completely.
Now we must say the following. You see, humans do not only need what plants give them through oxygen, they need the whole plant; with the exception of poisonous plants and plants that contain little of these substances, humans need all plants, not through respiration, but through nutrition. And here again there is a remarkable connection. You see, the plant consists of the root, if it is an annual plant – let's leave trees aside for now – the root, the herb, and the flower with fruit. Now, let's take a look at the root. The root is in the earth; it contains many salts because the salts are in the earth. And the root is attached to this earth with its fine rootlets; it constantly draws the salts out of the earth. So the root is what has a special connection with the mineral kingdom of the earth, with the salts.
Now, you see, gentlemen, it is the human head that is related to the whole earth — not the feet, but precisely the head is related to the earth. When a human being begins to be an earth human being in the womb, he initially has almost only his head. He begins with his head. The head is modeled after the entire universe, but also after the earth. And the head needs salts in particular. For it is from the head that the forces emanate which, for example, also permeate the human body with bones. Everything that makes the human being solid emanates from the formation of the head. When the head itself is still soft, as in the womb, it cannot form bones properly. As the head itself becomes harder and harder, it transfers its forces to the body so that humans and animals can form solid structures, especially bones. From this you can see that the root, which is related to the earth and contains salts—and salts are needed to form bones, which consist of carbonated calcium and phosphoric calcium— salts are that — from this you can see that the root is needed to supply the human head.
So, gentlemen, if, for example, you notice that a child is becoming weak in the head, how can you tell? You can sometimes tell by certain conditions: when a child becomes weak in the head, it easily gets worms in the intestines. Worms remain in the intestines when the powers of the head are too weak, because then the head does not exert a strong enough influence on the rest of the body, whereas worms find no habitat in humans when the powers of the head exert a strong influence on the intestines. From this you can see most clearly how wonderfully the human body is designed: everything in it is interconnected. And if you have a child who has worms, you should tell yourself that the child is weak in the head; you can also say — especially those who want to be educators must know such things — that if you have people later in life who are weak in the head, they had worms in their youth. What should one do when one observes this? Well, gentlemen, the simplest thing is to take yellow beets, carrots, and feed them to the children for a while — among other things; of course, one should not feed them only yellow beets, but for a while. Yellow beets are what is preferably plant roots in the earth. They contain a lot of salts; since they have the powers of the earth, when they are absorbed into the stomach, they are able to act through the blood and up into the head. Only substances rich in salt are able to penetrate the head. Substances rich in salt, root-like substances, make people strong through the head. That is what is extremely important, you see. And with yellow beets and carrots in particular, it is the case that the uppermost parts of the head become strong, which is exactly what humans need in order to become strong and firm on the inside, so that they do not become weak.
You see, when you look at a yellow beet plant, you will say to yourself: I see something very specific in this plant, which has grown mainly towards the root. Almost all of the yellow beet is root. When you have the plant, you are only interested in the root. The other part, the foliage, is just on top and is not very important. So this yellow beet is particularly suitable for nourishing the human head. So if you sometimes feel that you have a weakness in your head, a emptiness in your brain, and cannot think well, then it is also good to add yellow beets to your diet for a while. But of course, this helps most with children.
Now, if you compare the potato with the yellow turnip—yes, you see, it looks very different from the yellow turnip. As you know, the potato has leaves, but it has exactly what you eat, these tubers; they are stuck in the ground. Now, if you look at it superficially, you could say: In the case of the potato, these tubers are the roots. But that is not true; these tubers are not roots. If you look more closely, you will see everywhere that the roots are actually attached to the tubers in the ground. The actual roots are small rootlets that hang from the tubers; they fall off easily. When you take the potatoes out, they have already fallen off. already fallen off; but if you take them out when they are very fresh, they are still attached everywhere. When we take the tubers and eat them, we already have something like stems or herbs that only appear to form roots; in reality, they are stems or herbs; the leaves have been transformed. So this is something that is between the root and the herb inside. Therefore, the potato does not contain as much salt as, for example, the turnip; it is not as earthy; it grows in the earth, but it is not so closely related to the earth. And the potato has mainly carbohydrates, not so much salt, but carbohydrates.
Now you have to say the following to yourself: When I eat yellow beets, my body can actually be quite lazy, because it only needs to use the mouth juice, the saliva, to soften the yellow beet in the saliva; it only needs to use the gastric juice, the pepsin, and so on, and all the important stuff from the yellow beet goes to the head. Humans need the salts. These salts are supplied by everything that is plant root, and in particular by a root such as the yellow beet.
Now, when people eat potatoes, they first put them in their mouths and stomachs, where the potato is converted into starch through the effort of the body. Then it continues through the intestines. In order for it to enter the bloodstream and reach the head during further digestion, another effort must be made to convert the starch into sugar. Only then can it reach the head. So a greater amount of energy must be applied. Yes, you see, gentlemen, when I have to exert force on something external, I become weak. That is the secret of human beings: when I chop wood, that is, when I exert force externally, I become weak. But when I develop an inner strength within myself, transforming carbohydrates into starch and starch into sugar, I become strong. It is precisely by doing this, by asserting myself with sugar, by eating potatoes, that I become strong. When I apply force externally, I become weak; when I apply force internally, I become strong. So it is not a matter of simply filling oneself with food, but of the food developing strength in the body.
So one can say: Root vegetables — because all roots are like this, though not to the same degree as beetroot, which primarily affects the head — root vegetables give the body what it needs. Food that tends even slightly toward greens, that has carbohydrates, gives the body the strength it needs to work and move.
Now, I have already spoken about the potato; it makes people weak again, because it requires a tremendous amount of energy to digest, and above all, it prevents them from gaining strength in the long term. But the principle I have just explained to you applies precisely to the potato.
But to the same extent that potatoes are bad, all seed crops are good food: wheat, rye, and so on. They also contain carbohydrates, in such a way that humans can produce starch and sugar in the most favorable way, and thus actually make themselves as strong as possible through the carbohydrates in crops. Just think how strong people in the countryside become simply by eating a lot of bread made from crops! They must already have healthy bodies; especially if you can tolerate coarse bread, it is actually the healthiest food. You must have healthy bodies, but then the body becomes particularly strong through the preparation of starch and sugar.
Now a question arises. You see, humans have, one might say, come to realize on their own in their development that they should not eat crops in the same way as animals. Horses eat their oats almost as they grow. Animals eat their grain crops as they grow. For birds would have to be very poor at eating grain crops if they were dependent on someone cooking them first! People came up with the idea of cooking their crops themselves. Gentlemen, what happens when I cook crops? You see, by cooking crops, I enjoy them warm rather than cold. Now, if we want to process food internally, we have to apply heat. It is not possible without heat, gentlemen, to convert carbohydrates into starch and starch into sugar; this requires internal heating. If I heat the food externally and make it warm, then I am helping the body; it does not need to give off heat itself. So, first of all, the food is already absorbed into the fire, into the heat process, by cooking it. That is the first thing. But the second thing is that the food is completely transformed! Just think what happens to flour when I bake it into bread. It becomes completely different! But what makes it different? Well, first I grind the fruit. What does grinding mean? Making it very small. — Yes, you see, what I do with the grain fruits, grinding them, making them very small, I would have to do later in my own body! Everything I do there, I would have to do in my own body; by doing what I do there, I take it away from the body. The same applies when I roast them. All these things I do when cooking, I take away from the body, so that I bring the food into a state in which the body can digest it more easily.
You only need to compare what a difference there would be if people ate raw potatoes or if they ate them cooked. If people ate raw potatoes, the stomach would have to generate an enormous amount of heat to transform these raw potatoes, which are almost starch. However, the way it transforms them now is not sufficient. The potato then goes into the intestine. The intestine in turn has to expend a lot of energy. As a result, however, the potato gets stuck in the intestine; the subsequent forces are no longer sufficient to transport the potato further into the rest of the body. So if you eat raw potatoes, you either fill your stomach – and the intestine can no longer do anything with them – or you fill your intestine; but it doesn't go any further. However, if you prepare the potato by boiling it or cooking it in some other way, the stomach no longer has to work so hard on it, nor does the intestine; the potatoes pass into the blood and go up to the head.
So you see, by cooking food, especially food that is based on carbohydrates, you have the opportunity to support your nutrition.
As you know, all kinds of follies have come about in recent times, especially with regard to nutrition. These fads are actually in vogue today. There are “raw foodists” who don't want to cook anything at all, who want to eat everything raw. Well, of course, where does this come from? Because people from materialistic science no longer know how things are, and they don't want to learn about spiritual science. So they come up with something. The whole raw food diet is nothing but a fantasy. For a while, you can do it, because the body has to expend a lot of energy, I would say, whipping the body into shape, if you only eat raw food; but then it collapses all the more.
Now, gentlemen, let us turn to fats in general. Plants, almost all plants, contain fats, vegetable fats, which the plants produce from minerals. Yes, you see, fats do not enter the human body as easily as carbohydrates and salts. Salts are not actually changed at all. When you salt your soup, the salt you throw in goes up into your head almost unchanged as salt; you get it into your head. But when you eat potatoes, you no longer get potatoes into your head, but sugar; but the transformation takes place as I have told you. With fats, however, regardless of whether you eat vegetable or animal fats, things are not so simple. With fats, it is like this: when you eat fats, they are almost completely consumed by the mouth juices, stomach juices, and intestinal juices, and something completely different enters the blood, and animals and humans must first form the fats themselves in the intestines and blood through the power that the fats produce.
You see, that is the difference between fat and sugar or salt. Humans actually still obtain salt and sugar from nature, except that they convert the sugar from potatoes or rye and so on. So there is still something from nature in it. In the case of the fat that humans or animals have in them, there is nothing natural left; they have formed it themselves. But they would have no strength if they did not eat, and the intestines and blood need fat. So we can say that humans cannot produce salts themselves. If the human body did not absorb salts, it would never produce them itself. If humans did not consume carbohydrates, if they did not eat bread or other foods that provide carbohydrates, they would not be able to produce sugar. But if they couldn't produce sugar, they would always be weaklings. You owe that to sugar, gentlemen: because you are full of sweets through and through, you have strength. The moment you were no longer full of sweets through and through, you would no longer have strength, you would collapse.
You see, this extends to entire populations. We have populations that consume little sugar and also few substances that produce sugar. These are weak populations in terms of physical strength. We have populations that eat a lot of sugar; these are strong populations.
But humans do not have it so easy with fats. When humans have fats in them, as do animals, it is their own merit, the merit of their bodies. Fats are entirely their own product. So humans destroy the fats they take in from outside through plant fats and animal fats, and in overcoming the fats they now develop strength. With potatoes, rye, and wheat, humans develop their strength by transforming the substances; with the fats they eat, they develop strength by destroying the substances. When I destroy something from outside, I become tired and listless again. But when I destroy a very fatty beefsteak inside, I become weak, but this destruction of the very fatty beefsteak or the destruction of vegetable fat gives me strength again so that I can develop my own fat if my body is predisposed to do so. So you see that fatty foods have a completely different effect on the human body than carbohydrate foods.
Well, gentlemen, the human body is quite complicated, and it must be said that what I am telling you is a great deal of work; a lot has to happen in the human body for it to be able to destroy these vegetable fats. But let us now assume that humans enjoy herbs, i.e., the herb-like parts of plants. Yes, that is true: where herb-like parts are consumed, there is what humans obtain from plants in the form of fats. Why is the stalk such a hard substance? Because it transforms the leaves so that they become carbohydrates. But when the leaves remain green — the greener they are, the more fatty substance they provide. So when a person eats bread, for example, they do not absorb much fat from the bread. For example, they absorb more fat from watercress — the small plant with very small leaves — than they do from eating bread. This has created a need to eat bread with butter, with some fat, not on its own, or as country people do with bacon and so on, which is also fat, thus providing for two things.
When I eat bread, the bread goes up to the head because the root system of the plant goes up into the stalk — for the stalk has the root forces within it, even though it is a stalk and grows above ground —. It does not matter whether something is above ground, but whether it has roots. But the leaf, the green leaf, is not rooted. No green leaf grows down in the earth. In autumn, when the sun's forces are no longer strong, the stalk can ripen, towards late summer and autumn. But the leaf needs the strongest driving forces of the sun if it is to ripen; it grows towards the sun. So we can say: the herb acts primarily on the lungs and heart, while the root strengthens the head, and even the potato is such that it actually reaches the head. When we eat the herb, which can primarily provide us with vegetable fats, we strengthen our heart and lungs, the middle part of the human being, the chest. That, I would say, is the secret of human nutrition: if I want to have an effect on my head, then I prepare root food or stalk food or something like that; if I want to have an effect on my lungs and heart, I make myself a salad and so on. But because these things are already destroyed in the intestines and only the forces are effective, there is no need to cook them so much. That is why the leaves are made into salads. But everything that is supposed to affect the head cannot be made into salads; it must be cooked. Cooked food primarily affects the head. Salad-like food primarily affects the lungs, heart, and so on, building them up, nourishing them, through fats.
Now, gentlemen, it is not only the head and the middle, the chest, that need to be affected, but man must also have built up his digestive organs himself. He needs a stomach, intestines, kidneys, a liver, and so he must have built up his digestive organs himself. Now the interesting thing is this: in order to build up the digestive organs, the human being needs precisely the protein contained in plants, preferably as it is contained in the flowers and especially in the fruit itself. So we can say: The root primarily nourishes the head (see drawing, page 97); what is in the middle of the plant, the herb, primarily nourishes the chest, and what is in the fruit nourishes the abdomen.
So when we look at our seed fields, we can say: It is good that they are there, because they nourish our head. If we look at the lettuce we plant, at everything we eat in the leaves, which we do not need to cook because it can already be digested in the intestines, because it is only the nutrients that matter, then we get everything that sustains our chest organs. But if we look up at the plums, apples, and fruits that grow on the trees—yes, you see, we don't need to cook them much, because they are already cooked by the sun itself throughout the summer! So the internal ripening is already taking place; it is different from roots and things that are not ripened by the sun, but wither like stalks and so on. With fruit, we don't need to cook much, but only if we have a weak organism that cannot destroy the fruit in the intestines do we need to cook, make compotes, and the like. So, especially if someone has intestinal diseases, they must ensure that they get the fruit in the form of compote, as porridge, purée, and so on. But if someone has a completely healthy digestive system, a completely healthy intestinal system, then the fruit is there precisely to build up the abdomen, through the protein they contain. The protein in plant fruits builds up your stomach and everything else that humans have in their abdomen as digestive organs.
See what instinct has always been there! Of course, people did not know what I am explaining to you now in terms of concepts, but they knew it instinctively. That is why they always prepared a mixed diet of roots, herbs, and fruits, ate all these things, and also knew instinctively how much of each they needed.
But now you know that people do not only eat plants, but also enjoy animals, meat from animals, fat from animals, and so on.
You see, anthroposophy is not there to be fanatical or sectarian, but only to tell it like it is. And one cannot say that humans should only eat plants, or that they should also eat animal products, and so on, but one must say the following: there are simply people who, due to the forces they have inherited, cannot muster enough energy to do all the work necessary to break down plant fats to such an extent that the forces are generated in the body to produce its own fat. You see, those who eat only vegetable fats, yes, gentlemen, are people who either have to refrain from becoming fat, because the vegetable fat is destroyed — and this destruction generates energy — or they must have extremely good digestive health, so that it is easy for them to destroy the vegetable fats; then they gain the energy to produce their own fat. Most people, however, are such that they cannot actually do this, build up enough of their own fat, if they only destroy vegetable fat. But when people eat animal fat or meat, it is not completely destroyed. Vegetable fat does not pass through the intestines, it is destroyed in the intestines; but the fat contained in meat passes back into the human body. And it may be weaker — weaker than if it were fed only on vegetable fat. Therefore, we will distinguish between bodies that do not like fat, bodies that do not like to eat bacon, that do not like fatty foods in particular; these are bodies that destroy fat relatively easily and therefore want to form fat within themselves. The bodies say: I want to make the bacon I carry on me myself; I want to have my own bacon. — But when someone fills their plate with fatty foods, they don't say, “I want to make my own fat,” but rather, “The world should give me my fat,” because animal fat is absorbed into the body. This makes nutrition easier.
When children eat sugar, they don't do so for nutritional reasons. There is something nutritious in it when children eat sugar, but the child does not do it for nutritional reasons, but because of the sweetness. Now, the sweetness becomes conscious when eating sugar. But when a person ingests the fat from an ox, a pig, or whatever it may be, yes, gentlemen, it passes into his body. This satisfies their lust just as eating sugar satisfies the child's lust, only that it is not as satisfying, but the person already feels that there is lust in it. Now, of course, people need this inner lust for their inner existence. That is why they love meat. So meat is eaten especially when the body loves meat. |
But one must not be fanatical in this regard. There are people who cannot survive without eating meat. It must therefore always be carefully tested whether they can really live without meat. But if someone can do without meat, they will feel stronger than before when they switch from a meat diet to a vegetarian diet. You see, that is precisely the difficulty: some people cannot tolerate living without meat. But if they can, they will feel stronger when they become vegetarians, because they no longer need to store foreign fat in their bodies, but only get their own fat; this makes them feel strong.
And I can already say: I know this from my own experience, having gone through the efforts I have had to go through for a long time, for the last twenty-four years, that I could not have gone through them otherwise! Then I would not have been able to drive all night and give a lecture the next day and so on. Because, you see, what you have to prepare yourself when you are a vegetarian is taken away from you when you first let the animal do this work for you. That's the story. But you mustn't think that I am campaigning for vegetarianism in any way, because you really always have to try it out first to see whether the person in question can become a vegetarian or not; that is their disposition.
You see, gentlemen, this is particularly important with protein. Protein can also be transformed if you are able to destroy it in the intestines in the form in which you consume it, as plant protein; and then you gain strength. But as soon as the intestines become weak, you have to prepare it from the outside, i.e., consume protein properly, which is then animal protein, for example, because the chickens that lay the eggs are also animals. Well, protein is something that is actually completely misunderstood if you don't assess it from a spiritual-scientific point of view.
When I eat roots, their salts reach my head. When I eat salad, the forces—not the fats themselves, but the forces that are in the fats in the plants—reach my chest, lungs, and heart. When I eat fruit, the protein from the fruit does not reach my chest, but remains in my intestines. And the protein that comes from animals goes further than the intestines; it nourishes the body because the protein from animals spreads throughout the body. So one could say: if a person eats a lot of protein, they must become a well-nourished person. This has led to a situation in the materialistic age where people who have studied medicine have advised people to consume excessive amounts of protein; it has been claimed that 120 to 150 grams of protein are necessary. That's nonsense! Today we know that only a quarter of that amount is necessary for humans. And in fact, if people eat such an enormous amount of protein, which is unnecessary — well, you see, then what happened to a professor and his assistant will happen: they wanted to feed protein to a person who was malnourished. Now, it is assumed that when there is a particularly large amount of protein, it is converted in the human body and that the urine shows that he has eaten protein. Now they came to this conclusion with this person: the urine does not show that the protein is being processed inside the body. They did not realize that protein was passing through the intestines. The professor was furious about this. And the assistant said fearfully, his legs shaking: Yes, Professor, perhaps through the intestines? — Yes, what had happened? They had overfed the man with protein, but it did him no good, because the protein had gone from the stomach into the intestines and then out again. So it didn't enter the body at all. If you feed too much protein, it doesn't enter the body at all, but goes into the feces. - But he does get something out of it, because before it comes out, it stays in the intestines and becomes poisonous, intoxicating the whole body, poisoning the body! That's what happens when you eat too much protein. And this poisoning very often leads to arteriosclerosis, so that many people get arteriosclerosis too early - simply because they are overfed with protein.
So, as I have just explained, it is important to learn about nutrition. Because most people actually very often believe that the more you eat, the better nourished you are. That is not true; sometimes you are much better nourished if you eat less, because then you do not poison yourself.
And that's it: you have to know how these individual substances work. You have to know that salts primarily affect the head, that carbohydrates, such as those found in our staple foods, bread and potatoes, have more of an effect on the lung system and the throat system — lungs, throat, palate, and so on — that fats primarily affect the heart and blood vessels, arteries and veins, and that protein primarily affects the abdominal organs. The head does not benefit from protein at all. The protein that is in the head — of course, the head must also be made up of protein, because it consists of living substance — the protein must also be produced by the human being himself. So if you overfeed him, you must not believe that he will get a particularly healthy brain as a result, but on the contrary, he will get a poisoned brain.
I may have to talk about nutrition for another hour. But that's fine, because such questions are very fruitful. So, next Saturday at nine o'clock.
Protein: abdominal organs
Fats: heart and blood vessels
Carbohydrates: lungs, throat, palate
Salts: head
